VIETNAMESE AUDITING STANDARDS SYSTEM
Quality Control Standard No. 1: Quality Control of Auditing, Reviewing Financial Statements, Assurance Services and Other Related Services (VSQC1)
(Issued together with Circular No. 214/2012/TT-BTC)
(December 6, 2012, Ministry of Finance)
I/ General Regulations
Scope of application
1. This Quality Control Standard (VSQC1) specifies and guides the responsibilities of audit firms regarding the quality control system for auditing and reviewing financial statements, assurance services, and other related services.. When implementing this Standard, relevant professional ethics standards and regulations should be consulted.
2. Other Vietnamese auditing standards provide additional regulations and guidance on the responsibilities of audit firm officers and employees regarding quality control procedures for specific types of services. For example, Vietnamese Auditing Standard No. 220 provides regulations and guidance on quality control procedures for financial statement audits.
3. The quality control system includes policies established to achieve the objectives set out in paragraph 11 of this Standard and the procedures necessary to implement and monitor compliance with those policies.
Basis for application
4. This Standard applies to all audit firms performing audits and reviews of financial statements, assurance services, and other related services. The content and scope of the policies and procedures that each audit firm develops to comply with this Standard will depend on factors such as the size and specifics of the audit firm's operations, and whether or not the audit firm belongs to a network.
5. This Standard specifies the objectives of audit firms in complying with the Standard and the regulations developed to ensure that audit firms meet these objectives. In addition, this Standard includes guidance on application (see paragraph 08 of this Standard), an introduction appropriate to the specific context to help understand the Standard correctly, and a glossary of terms.
6. The objective of developing the provisions of this Standard is to assist auditing firms:
(1) Understand the tasks that need to be performed;
(2) Decide whether further work is needed to achieve the goal.
7. The general provisions section sets out the regulations that must be followed.
8. Where necessary, the application guidelines provide further clarification of the regulations and instructions for implementing them, specifically:
(1) Provide a more detailed explanation of the meaning or scope of the regulations;
(2) Give examples of policies and procedures that are appropriate to the specific circumstances.
Guidance provides instructions on how to apply the provisions appropriately. Application guidance may provide necessary information to help understand the provisions of the standard. Where necessary, application guidance may also provide notes for audit firms performing audits in the public sector and small audit firms. These notes help in applying the provisions of this Standard, but do not limit or lessen the responsibility of the audit firm to apply and comply with the provisions of this Standard.
9. The “Explanation of Terms” section explains the meaning of the terms as used in this Standard. The terms are explained to help understand and apply this Standard consistently and do not replace terms developed for other purposes, such as in laws and regulations. The glossary of terms of Vietnamese auditing standards includes both the terms in this Standard and also explains other terms in this Standard to help understand and apply the standard consistently.
10. Auditors, service providers, and audit firms must comply with the provisions of this Standard in the performance of audits, reviews of financial statements, assurance services, and other related services.
The audited entity (client) and other entities and individuals involved in the audit, review of financial statements, assurance services, and other related services must have the necessary understanding of the provisions and guidance of this Standard to cooperate with the auditor, the service provider, and the audit firm in the performance of the audit, review of financial statements, assurance services, and other related services.
Target
11. The objective of an auditing firm is to establish and maintain a quality control system to provide reasonable assurance that:
(a) The audit firm and its officers and employees have complied with professional standards, laws and relevant regulations;
(b) The report issued by the auditing firm is appropriate to the specific circumstances.
Explanation of terms
12. In this Standard, the following terms are understood as follows:
(a) Date of report: Is the date auditor or The person performing the service contract chooses to sign. and recorded in the audit report or service contract report.;
(b) Documents and records related to the service contract: These are document, The record documents the work performed, the results achieved, and the conclusions reached. auditor or service provider (in some cases referred to as "working papers");
(c) Board member responsible for overall service contract: As the legal representative or authorized person acting on behalf of the Board of Directors of the auditing firm, you are responsible for the execution of the service contract, signing the report, and bearing overall responsibility for the issued report;
(d) Review of service contract quality control: This is a process designed and performed on or before the date of report issuance to provide an objective assessment of the significant judgments of the service contract team and the team's conclusions in forming the report. The review of service contract quality control applies only to audits of the financial statements of listed organizations and other service contracts (if any) that the audit firm deems necessary to review;
(e) Quality Control Reviewer of the Service Contract: A member of the Board of Directors, another individual within or outside the audit firm with appropriate competence, or a group of such individuals, but not a member of the service contract team, with sufficient experience and appropriate authority to provide an objective assessment of the significant judgments and conclusions reached by the service contract team in forming the report;
(f) Service Contract Execution Team: Includes members of the Board of Directors responsible for the overall service contract, and the practicing auditor responsible for the service contract. auditor and officers and staff performing the service contract and any individuals employed by the audit firm or network company to perform the procedures for the service contract. The service contract team does not include external experts employed by the audit firm or network company;
(g) Auditing firm: Being a business that meets the requirements to conduct auditing services as stipulated by the Law on Independent Auditing and other relevant legal regulations;
(h) Verification: A verification procedure applied to a completed service contract, designed to provide evidence of the service team's compliance with the audit firm's quality control policies and procedures;
(i) Listed organization: Is a legal entity whose shares, stocks, or debt instruments are offered or listed on a stock exchange or traded in accordance with the regulations of the stock exchange or other similar institutions;
(j) Monitoring: The process of continuous review and evaluation of the audit firm's quality control system, including periodic re-examination of a selected number of completed service contracts to provide the audit firm with reasonable assurance that its quality control system is functioning effectively;
(k) Network company: A company or legal entity belonging to the same network;
(l) Network: Is the connection between organizations to:
(i) Towards cooperation;
(ii) Aiming for the sharing of profits or costs, or jointly owning, controlling or managing, having common quality control policies and procedures, a common business strategy, using a common brand, or sharing a significant portion of professional resources.
(m) Members of the Board of Directors: Being a qualified professional and entrusted by the auditing firm with the responsibility of performing professional services under a contract; holding a title such as General Director, Deputy General Director, Director, Deputy Director of the Company, or possibly Director, Deputy Director of a Branch;
(n) Personnel: Includes members of the Board of Directors and officers and employees;
(o) Professional standards: Including auditing standards, and relevant professional ethics standards and regulations;
(p) Reasonable assurance: In this Standard, reasonable assurance is an assurance that is high but not absolute;
(q) Relevant professional ethical standards and regulations: These are the professional ethical regulations that the service contract team and the quality control reviewer of the service contract must comply with, typically including Parts A and B of accounting and auditing professional ethical standards and related regulations.
(r) Officers and employees: All professional officers and employees hired by the auditing firm through employment contracts, excluding members of the Board of Directors;
(s) Individuals outside the firm with appropriate qualifications: Individuals not affiliated with the auditing firm who possess the professional qualifications, competence, and experience to perform a quality control review role equivalent to that of a member of the Board of Directors responsible for the overall service contract, for example, a member of the Board of Directors of another auditing firm or an individual with appropriate experience from a professional organization whose members may perform audits and reviews of historical financial information or assurance services and other related services, or an individual from an organization that provides appropriate quality control services.
II/ Standard Content
Request
Apply and comply with relevant regulations.
13. Individuals within the audit firm responsible for establishing and maintaining the firm's quality control system must have a thorough understanding of the entire content of this Standard, including the application guidance, in order to comprehend the objective of the Standard and correctly apply its provisions and guidance.
14. Audit firms must comply with each provision and guidance of this Standard when providing audit and review services for financial statements, assurance services, and other related services (see guidance in paragraph A1 of this Standard).
15. The rules and guidelines are designed to help audit firms achieve the objectives set forth in this Standard, and the appropriate application of the provisions of this Standard will provide sufficient basis for achieving those objectives. However, given that circumstances are subject to change and are difficult to predict, audit firms must consider whether specific issues or circumstances require them to develop policies and procedures other than those set forth in this Standard in order to achieve their stated objectives.
Elements of a quality control system
16. Audit firms must establish and maintain a quality control system that includes policies and procedures for each of the following elements:
(a) The Board of Directors' responsibility for quality in the audit firm;
(b) Relevant professional ethical standards and regulations;
(c) Accepting and maintaining specific customer relationships and service contracts;
(d) Human resources;
(e) Performing the service contract;
(f) Monitoring.
17. Audit firms must establish in writing their policies and procedures and must disseminate these policies and procedures to their clients. all Officers and employees of the enterprise (see guidance in paragraphs A2 – A3 of this Standard).
The Board of Directors' responsibility for quality in an auditing firm.
18. Audit firms must develop policies and procedures to foster an internal culture based on the understanding that quality is essential when performing service contracts. These policies and procedures must require the CEO/Director or the Chairman of the Board of Members (where appropriate) of the audit firm to bear ultimate responsibility for the firm's quality control system (see guidance in paragraphs A4–A5 of this Standard).
19. The auditing firm must establish policies and procedures to ensure that any individual assigned by the CEO/Director or Chairman of the Board (to the extent appropriate) to manage the firm's quality control system has the necessary experience, appropriate capabilities, and authority to perform that responsibility (see guidance in paragraph A6 of this Standard).
Relevant professional ethical standards and regulations
20. Audit firms must establish policies and procedures to provide reasonable assurance that the audit firm and all its officers and employees comply with relevant professional ethical standards and regulations (see guidance in paragraphs A7–A10 of this Standard).
Independence
21. Audit firms must establish policies and procedures to provide reasonable assurance that the audit firm, all its officers and, where necessary, other parties subject to standards and regulations on independence (including officers and employees of the network firm) will maintain the necessary independence in accordance with relevant professional standards and regulations. Such policies and procedures enable the audit firm (see guidance in paragraph A10 of this Standard):
(a) Disseminate the independence requirements to the officers and employees of the enterprise and, where necessary, to other parties subject to independence regulations;
(b) Identify and assess any circumstances and relationships that may threaten independence, and take appropriate measures to eliminate or reduce such threat to an acceptable level by employing safeguards or, if necessary, withdrawing from the service contract if permitted by law and regulations.
22. Those policies and procedures must require (see guidance in paragraph A10 of this Standard):
(a) Members of the Board of Directors responsible for the overall service contract shall provide the audit firm with the necessary information relating to the service contract, including the scope of services, to enable the audit firm to assess the overall impact, if any, on the independence requirements;
(b) Officers and employees of the auditing firm must immediately notify the auditing firm of any circumstances and relationships that may threaten its independence so that the firm can take appropriate measures;
(c) Accumulate and exchange relevant information with appropriate officers and staff within the audit firm to:
(i) The auditing firm and its officers and employees can determine whether they meet the independence requirements;
(ii) The auditing firm may maintain and update records relating to its independence;
(iii) The audit firm may take appropriate measures toward identified risks that threaten independence and whose impact exceeds acceptable levels.
23. Audit firms must develop policies and procedures to provide reasonable assurance that they are notified of any breaches of independence and that appropriate measures are taken to address such breaches. These policies and procedures must include the following provisions (see guidance in paragraph A10 of this Standard):
(a) Officers and employees of the audit firm must immediately notify the audit firm of any violations of independence that they become aware of;
(b) The audit firm must immediately communicate any detected violations of policies and procedures with:
(i) The member of the Board of Directors responsible for the overall service contract – who must work with the auditing firm to handle violations;
(ii) Other relevant officers and employees within the audit firm and network, if necessary, as well as other parties, must comply with the independence regulations;
(c) Members of the Board of Directors responsible for the overall service contract and other individuals referred to in paragraph 23(b)(ii) This Standard shall communicate immediately with the audit firm, if necessary, the measures taken to address the issue in order to help the audit firm determine whether further measures are required.
24. At least once a year, the auditing firm must obtain written confirmation of compliance with the firm's independence policies and procedures from all officers and employees of the firm who are subject to the standards and regulations on ethics relating to independence (see guidance in paragraphs A10–A11 of this Standard).
25. Audit firms must develop policies and procedures (see guidance in paragraph A10 of this Standard):
(a) Establish criteria for determining the need for safeguards to reduce the risk from familiarity to an acceptable level when assigning responsibility to a Board member/practicing auditor (hereinafter referred to as “the person in charge of the service contract”) perform service contract for a customer for a long time;
(b) For the audit of financial statements of listed organizations, it is required that the member of the Board of Directors in charge of the overall audit be rotated. and the practicing auditor in charge The audit and other parties involved should be rotated if necessary, after a specified period in accordance with the relevant professional ethics standards and regulations (see guidance in paragraphs A12–A17 of this Standard).
Accepting and maintaining customer relationships and specific service contracts.
26. Audit firms must establish policies and procedures for accepting and maintaining client relationships and specific service contracts to provide reasonable assurance that the audit firm will only accept or maintain client relationships and service contracts if the audit firm:
(a) Possess sufficient professional competence and capacity to perform the service contract, including the necessary time and resources (see guidance in paragraphs A18 and A23 of this Standard);
(b) Able to comply with relevant professional ethical standards and regulations;
(c) The integrity of audited entity/client and no information that would lead the auditing firm to conclude that audited entityThat customer lacks integrity (see guidance in paragraphs A19–A20, A23 of this Standard).
27. Those policies and procedures must require:
(a) The audit firm gathers the necessary information in each specific circumstance before accepting a new client or when deciding whether to continue a relationship with an existing client and when considering accepting to provide new services to an existing client (see guidance in paragraphs A21, A23 of this Standard);
(b) When considering accepting a service contract with a new or existing client, if a potential conflict of interest is identified, the audit firm must determine whether or not to accept the service contract;
(c) If problems are discovered and the audit firm decides to accept or maintain a client relationship or a particular contract, the audit firm must document in its records how those problems were resolved.
28. Audit firms must establish policies and procedures for maintaining service contracts and client relationships. These policies and procedures shall specify the circumstances under which an audit firm obtains information which, if previously known, would lead to the firm's refusal of the contract. These policies and procedures shall take into account:
(a) Legal and professional liability applicable to each specific circumstance, including whether the audit firm is required to report to the authority that appointed the entity performing the service or, in some cases, to competent state authorities;
(b) The ability to withdraw from a service contract or to withdraw from both a service contract and a customer relationship (see guidance in paragraphs A22–A23 of this Standard).
Human resources
29. Audit firms must establish policies and procedures to provide reasonable assurance that they have sufficient personnel with the necessary professional qualifications, competence, and commitment to professional ethics to:
(a) Perform the service contract in accordance with professional standards, laws and relevant regulations;
(b) Allows the auditing firm to issue a report appropriate to the specific circumstances (see guidance in paragraphs A24–A29 of this Standard).
Assigning teams to execute service contracts.
30. The auditing firm must assign responsibility for each service contract to a member of the Board of Directors responsible for the overall service contract and must develop policies and procedures to stipulate:
(a) The identity and role of the Board member responsible for the overall service contract shall be discussed with key members of the Board of Directors and the Board of Management of audited entity/client;
(b) The member of the Board of Directors responsible for the overall service contract must have the appropriate professional qualifications, competence and authority to perform his/her duties;
(c) The responsibilities of the Board member in charge of the overall service contract are clearly defined and must be communicated to that Board member (see guidance in paragraph A30 of this Standard).
31. Audit firms must establish policies and procedures for appointing suitable personnel with the necessary professional qualifications and competence to:
(a) Perform service contracts in accordance with professional standards, laws and relevant regulations;
(b) Allow the auditing firm to issue a report appropriate to the specific circumstances (see guidance in paragraph A31 of this Standard).
Execute the service contract
32. Audit firms must develop policies and procedures to provide reasonable assurance that service contracts are performed in accordance with professional standards, relevant laws and regulations, and that the audit firm issues reports appropriate to the specific circumstances. These policies and procedures must include:
(a) Issues relating to enhancing consistency in the quality of service contract performance (see guidance in paragraphs A32–A33 of this Standard);
(b) Supervisory responsibilities (see guidance in paragraph A34 of this Standard);
(c) Review responsibilities (see guidance in paragraph A35 of this Standard).
33. Policies and procedures regarding the review responsibilities of audit firms must be determined on the principle that members of the service team with more experience review the work of less experienced members of the team.
Seek advice
34. Audit firms must develop policies and procedures to provide reasonable assurance that:
(a) Appropriate consultation should be undertaken on complex or contentious matters;
(b) Adequate resources are available to enable the implementation of appropriate consultations;
(c) The content, scope, and conclusions from the consultation must be recorded and agreed upon by both the consulting party and the consultant;
(d) The conclusions drawn from consultations must be implemented (see guidance in paragraphs A36–A40 of this Standard).
Reviewing the quality control of service contracts
35. Audit firms must establish policies and procedures requiring quality control reviews of service contracts to objectively assess the significant judgments of the service team and the team's conclusions in forming the report. These policies and procedures must:
(a) Require a review of quality control for all audits of financial statements of listed organizations;
(b) Provide criteria for evaluating all audits and reviews of financial statements, as well as assurance and other related services, to determine whether a quality control review is required (see guidance in paragraph A41 of this Standard);
(c) Require a review of quality control for all service contracts that meet the criteria set out in paragraph 35(b) of this Standard (if applicable).
36. Audit firms must establish policies and procedures specifying the content, timing, and scope of the review of the quality control of service contracts. These policies and procedures must stipulate that reports on service contracts must not be dated before the completion of the review of the quality control of the service contract (see guidance in paragraphs A42–A43 of this Standard).
37. Audit firms must establish policies and procedures to ensure that the quality control review of service contracts includes:
(a) Discuss important issues with the Board member responsible for overall service contract;
(b) Review financial statements or other information and draft reports;
(c) Review the documents and records related to the selected service contract concerning significant judgments and conclusions of the service contract team;
(d) Evaluate the conclusions of the service team to form the report and consider whether the draft report is appropriate (see guidance in paragraph A44 of this Standard).
38. For the audit of financial statements of listed organizations, the auditing firm must develop policies and procedures to ensure that the quality control review of the audit takes into account the following issues:
(a) The audit team's assessment of the independence of the audit firm in relation to the specific audit;
(b) Whether the audit team has sought the necessary advice on matters of differing opinion, complex or contentious issues, and the conclusions drawn from such consultation;
(c) Do the documents and records selected for review reflect the work performed relating to the material judgments and support the conclusions of the audit team (see guidance in paragraphs A45–A46 of this Standard)?
Criteria for the competence of reviewers in the quality control of service contracts.
39. Audit firms must establish policies and procedures for appointing reviewers for the quality control of service contracts and set criteria for the competence of reviewers through:
(a) The professional qualifications required to perform the review task, including the necessary experience and authority (see guidance in paragraph A47 of this Standard);
(b) The ability of the quality control reviewer of a service contract to be consulted on the service contract without compromising the reviewer's objectivity (see guidance in paragraph A48 of this Standard).
40. Audit firms must develop policies and procedures to maintain the objectivity of reviewers in the quality control of service contracts (see guidance in paragraphs A49–A51 of this Standard).
41. The audit firm's policies and procedures must stipulate the replacement of the reviewer for the quality control of a service contract when the reviewer's objectivity is no longer guaranteed.
Documents and records related to the review of quality control of service contracts.
42. Audit firms must establish policies and procedures for documentation and records related to the review of quality control of service contracts, which stipulate that documents and records concerning the following contents must be retained:
(a) The procedures stipulated in the audit firm's policy regarding the review and control of service contracts have been implemented;
(b) The quality control review of the service contract was completed on or before the date of this report;
(c) The reviewer does not find any unresolved issues that would lead the reviewer to believe that the critical judgments and conclusions of the service contract team are inappropriate.
Differences in perspective
43. The audit firm must develop policies and procedures to address and resolve differences of opinion within the team performing the service contract with the consultant or between the Board of Directors member responsible for the overall service contract and the quality control reviewer of the service contract (see guidance in paragraphs A52-A53 of this Standard).
44. Those policies and procedures must stipulate:
(a) The conclusions drawn must be documented and implemented;
(b) A report on a service contract shall not be dated before the date on which the remaining differences of opinion (as referred to in paragraph 43 of this Standard) are resolved.
Documents and records related to service contracts.
Complete the official documentation for the service contract.
45. Audit firms must establish policies and procedures requiring the service team to promptly finalize the formal documentation of the service contract after completing the service contract report (see guidance in paragraphs A54–A55 of this Standard).
Confidentiality, security, integrity, accessibility, and recoverability of service contract documents and records.
46. Audit firms must establish policies and procedures to maintain the confidentiality, security, integrity, accessibility, and recoverability of documentation and records related to service contracts (see guidance in paragraphs A56–A59 of this Standard).
Storing documents and records related to service contracts.
47. Audit firms must establish policies and procedures for retaining documentation and records related to service contracts for a sufficiently long period to meet the requirements of the audit firm or the requirements of law and regulations (see guidance in paragraphs A60–A63 of this Standard).
Monitor
Monitoring the quality control policies and procedures of the auditing firm.
48. The auditing firm must establish a monitoring process to ensure reasonable assurance that policies and procedures relating to the quality control system are appropriate, adequate, and effective. This process must:
(a) Continuous review and evaluation of the audit firm's quality control system, including periodic review of at least one completed service contract by each member of the Board of Directors responsible for the overall service contract;
(b) Requires that responsibility for the monitoring process be assigned to one or more members of the Board of Directors or other persons with appropriate experience and authority within the audit firm to perform that responsibility;
(c) Require that those performing the service contract or reviewing the quality control of the service contract not participate in the inspection of that service contract (see guidance in paragraphs A64–A68 of this Standard).
Evaluate, discuss, and address any defects identified.
49. The auditing firm must assess the impact of deficiencies discovered through the monitoring process and determine whether:
(a) The deficiencies occurred but were not sufficient to indicate that the audit firm's quality control system was inadequate to provide the audit firm with reasonable assurance that it complied with relevant professional standards, laws and regulations, and that the reports issued by the audit firm were appropriate to the circumstances; or
(b) Are those defects systemic, recurring, or other serious defects that require prompt correction?
50. The audit firm shall communicate with the members of the Board of Directors responsible for the overall service contract and relevant officers and employees about deficiencies discovered through the monitoring process and propose appropriate corrective actions (see guidance in paragraph A69 of this Standard).
51. Appropriate corrective actions proposed for detected deficiencies shall include one or more of the following:
(a) Take appropriate corrective action relating to each service contract or each officer or employee of the audit firm;
(b) Discuss the findings with individuals responsible for training and professional development;
(c) Changes to quality control policies and procedures;
(d) Disciplinary action against individuals who fail to comply with the audit firm's policies and procedures, especially those who repeatedly violate them.
52. Audit firms must develop policies and procedures to handle situations where the results of monitoring procedures indicate that the service contract report may be inappropriate or that procedures were omitted during the performance of the service contract. Such policies and procedures must require the audit firm to determine which subsequent actions are appropriate to comply with professional standards, laws, and relevant regulations, and to consider whether legal counsel is needed.
53. At least once a year, the audit firm must communicate the results of monitoring its quality control system to the members of the Board of Directors responsible for the service contract and other relevant individuals within the audit firm, including the General Director/Director or the Board of General Directors/Board of Directors, if necessary. The information exchanged must be sufficient to enable the audit firm and the aforementioned individuals to take timely and appropriate action, when necessary, in accordance with their assigned duties and responsibilities. The information exchanged must include:
(a) Description of the monitoring procedures performed;
(b) Conclusions drawn from monitoring procedures;
(c) Description of systemic, recurring, or other serious deficiencies and actions taken to address or correct those deficiencies.
54. Several audit firms operate within the same network, and to ensure consistency, these firms may perform certain supervisory procedures as required by the network. If the audit firms within the same network operate under common supervisory policies and procedures designed to comply with this Standard, and the audit firms rely on that supervisory system, then the audit firm's policies and procedures shall stipulate that:
(a) At least once a year, the network shall disseminate information about the scope, extent and overall results of the monitoring process to relevant individuals in the network companies;
(b) The network must communicate promptly with relevant individuals in the network companies about any deficiencies discovered in the quality control system in order to take necessary actions.
These regulations help the members of the Board of Directors responsible for overall service contracts in network companies to have confidence in the results of the monitoring process carried out within the network, unless the auditing firm or the network stipulates otherwise.
Complaints and accusations
55. Audit firms must develop policies and procedures to obtain reasonable assurance that the audit firm will appropriately address:
(a) Complaints and allegations that the audit firm has performed work that does not comply with professional standards, laws and relevant regulations;
(b) Allegations of non-compliance with the audit firm's quality control system.
The monitoring process also requires audit firms to establish clear communication channels so that their officers and staff can raise concerns without fear of retaliation (see guidance in paragraph A70 of this Standard).
56. During the investigation of complaints and allegations, if deficiencies are found in the design or implementation of the audit firm's quality control policies and procedures, or if non-compliance with the quality control system by individuals is discovered, the audit firm shall take appropriate action as prescribed in paragraph 51 of this Standard (see guidance in paragraphs A71–A72 of this Standard).
Documents and records related to the quality control system.
57. Audit firms must develop policies and procedures for appropriate documentation and records to provide evidence of the performance of each element in the audit firm's quality control system (see guidance in paragraphs A73–A75 of this Standard).
58. Audit firms must establish policies and procedures for the retention of documents and records for a sufficiently long period to allow individuals performing supervisory procedures to assess the audit firm's compliance with its quality control system, or for a longer period if required by law and regulations.
59. Audit firms must establish policies and procedures specifying the documentation and records related to complaints and allegations, as well as the measures for handling such complaints and allegations.
III/ Application Instructions
When implementing this Standard, reference should be made to Vietnamese Auditing Standard No. 200.
Apply and comply with relevant regulations.
Note for small audit firms (guidance in paragraph 14 of this Standard)
A1. Small audit firms must still comply with the provisions of this Standard, such as the provisions on policies and procedures for assigning appropriate personnel to the audit team (see paragraph 31 of this Standard), the provisions on review responsibilities (see paragraph 33 of this Standard), and the provisions on annual communication of supervisory results with the members of the Board of Directors responsible for the overall audit in the audit firm (see paragraph 53 of this Standard).
Elements of a quality control system (Guidance in paragraph 17 of this Standard)
A2. In general, disseminating quality control policies and procedures to audit firm staff includes describing the quality control policies and procedures, the objectives to be achieved, and conveying the message that each individual is responsible for quality and must comply with these policies and procedures. Encouraging audit firm staff to share their views or concerns regarding quality control demonstrates the importance of gathering feedback on the audit firm's quality control system.
Note for small auditing firms
A3. For smaller audit firms, documentation, records, and communication regarding policies and procedures may be less standardized and narrower in scope compared to larger audit firms.
The Board of Directors' responsibility for quality in an auditing firm.
Promoting an internal culture of quality. (Refer to paragraph 18 of this Standard)
A4. The leadership of an audit firm and the exemplary models it establishes significantly influence the firm's internal culture. Promoting a quality-oriented internal culture depends on clear, consistent, and frequent actions and messages from all levels of management within the audit firm. These actions and messages must consistently emphasize the firm's quality control policies and procedures and require:
(a) Perform work in accordance with professional standards, laws and relevant regulations;
(b) Issue reports appropriate to the specific circumstances.
These actions and messages will encourage a culture of recognizing and rewarding high-quality work. These actions and messages can be disseminated through training courses, workshops, meetings, formal or informal seminars, action strategies, internal newsletters, or guidance documents. They can also be incorporated into the audit firm's internal documentation, records, and training materials, and into management and staff performance review procedures to support and reinforce the audit firm's perspective on the importance of quality and how to achieve it.
A5. To foster an internal culture of quality, it is especially important for audit firm leaders to recognize that the top priority in the audit firm's business strategy is to ensure the quality of all service contracts undertaken. Tasks needed to promote this internal culture include:
(a) Develop policies and procedures for performance evaluation, compensation, and promotion opportunities (including incentive systems) for audit firm staff to demonstrate the audit firm's top commitment to quality;
(b) Assign management responsibilities in such a way that material concerns do not interfere with the quality of work performed;
(c) Provide adequate resources for the development, archiving of documents and records, and support for the audit firm's quality control policies and procedures.
Assigning responsibilities for managing the quality control system of the auditing firm. (Guidance in paragraph 19 of this Standard)
A6. Sufficient and appropriate experience and capabilities will enable individuals responsible for the audit firm's quality control system to identify and understand quality control issues and to develop appropriate policies and procedures. The necessary authority will enable those individuals to implement these policies and procedures.
Standards and regulations regarding professional ethics.
Adhere to relevant professional ethical standards and regulations. (Guidance in paragraph 20 of this Standard)
A7. The Code of Professional Ethics for Accountants and Auditors stipulates the basic principles of professional ethics, including:
(a) Integrity;
(b) Objectivity;
(c) Professional competence and prudence;
(d) Security;
(e) Professional qualifications.
A8. The Code of Professional Ethics for Accountants and Auditors prescribes and guides the application of the general framework in specific situations. The Code of Professional Ethics also provides examples of appropriate safeguards to prevent risks leading to non-compliance with fundamental principles and examples of situations where no safeguards exist to prevent such risks.
A9. Fundamental principles are reinforced:
(1) By the business leader auditing;
(2) Through education and training;
(3) Through monitoring;
(4) Through the process of handling non-compliance.
Explanation of the terms “Auditing firm”, “Network” and “Network company” (guidance in paragraphs 20-25 of this Standard)
A10. The interpretation of the terms “Audit firm,” “Network,” or “Network company” in the Code of Professional Ethics for Accountants and Auditors may differ from the interpretation of the terms in this Standard. For example, the Code of Professional Ethics for Accountants and Auditors defines “Audit firm” as:
(i) An independent auditing firm providing auditing services as prescribed by law (such as Audit Firm A, Audit Firm B having independent legal personality);
(ii) An organization that controls the enterprises mentioned in point (a) (such as a parent company, an international subsidiary);
(iii) An organization under the control of the enterprises mentioned in point (a) (such as a company branch).
The professional code of ethics for accountants and auditors also provides guidance on the terms "network" and "network firm".
To comply with the provisions in paragraphs 20–25 of this Standard, the terms used in the Code of Professional Ethics for Accountants and Auditors will be applied to understand this Standard and its professional ethical provisions.
Written confirmation (guidance in paragraph 24 of this Standard)
A11. Written confirmation as prescribed in paragraph 24 of this Standard This can be in the form of paper documents or electronic documents. By collecting written confirmation and taking appropriate action upon receiving information about non-compliance, the audit firm will demonstrate the importance of independence and disseminate this information to its officers and staff.
The risks of familiarity (guidance in paragraph 25 of this Standard)
A12. The Code of Professional Ethics for Accountants and Auditors stipulates that the risk of familiarity can result from assigning responsibility to the same person to perform an assurance service contract for a client over an extended period. The Code of Professional Ethics also provides appropriate measures to prevent such risk.
A13. Determining appropriate criteria for the risk from familiarity may include identifying issues such as:
(1) The content of the service contract, including the extent to which the contract relates to the public interest;
(2) The time the service contract manager is responsible for a customer.
Examples of measures to mitigate the risks of familiarity include rotating those responsible for service contracts or requiring reviews of the quality control of service contracts.
A14. The Code of Professional Ethics for Accountants and Auditors stipulates and provides guidance on the risks arising from familiarity commonly encountered when auditing the financial statements of listed organizations. For these audits, the Code of Professional Ethics for Accountants and Auditors stipulates that the member of the Board of Directors responsible for the overall audit must be rotated. and the practicing auditor in charge of the audit after a certain period of time, usually not more than 3 year, and also issued related regulations and guidelines.
Note for auditing firms conduct audit in the public sector
A15. Laws may provide for measures to protect the independence of public sector auditors. However, independence can still be threatened even with legal protections in place. Therefore, when developing policies and procedures as prescribed in paragraphs 20–25 of this Standard, public sector auditors may refer to the provisions of the State Audit Office and address threats to independence based on the actual situation.
A16. Listed entities regulated and guided in paragraphs 25 and A14 of this Standard are not common in the public sector. However, entities in the public sector may be large, complex, or involve public interests. Therefore, based on the audit firm's quality control policies and procedures, the audit firm may determine that the audited entity in the public sector is in a position to warrant expanding quality control procedures.
A17. In the public sector, the law may provide for the appointment and tenure of the Board of Directors responsible for the overall audit. Therefore, the regulations regarding the rotation of the Board of Directors responsible for the overall audit of public sector entities may not be as stringent as those for publicly listed organizations. However, for public sector entities deemed significant under paragraph A16 of this Standard, public sector audit organizations may develop policies and procedures to enhance compliance with the requirement for rotation of the Board of Directors responsible for the overall audit in order to serve the public interest.
Accepting and maintaining customer relationships and specific service contracts.
Professional competence, capabilities, and resources(as per guidance in paragraph 26(a) of this Standard)
A18. To determine whether an audit firm has the professional competence, capabilities, and resources to undertake a new service contract for a new or existing client, the audit firm must review the specific requirements of the service contract and the competence of the Board of Directors responsible for the overall service contract and other relevant members:
(1) Do the officers and employees of the auditing firm have knowledge of the industry, field of activity or related issues?
(2) Do the officers and staff of the audit firm have experience with relevant legal regulations and reporting requirements, or are they able to effectively acquire the necessary skills and knowledge?
(3) Does the auditing firm have sufficient personnel with the necessary professional competence and capabilities?
(4) Whether or not experts are available, if needed;
(5) Are there individuals who meet the criteria and competency requirements to perform quality control review of the service contract?
(6) Whether the auditing firm is able to complete the service contract within the deadline for submitting the report.
Customer integrity (Guidance in paragraph 26(c) of this Standard)
A19. Examples of issues to consider related to the integrity of audited entityCustomers include:
(1) Names and identities of principal owners, key members of the Board of Directors and the Management Board audited entity/client;
(2) Customer's operating characteristics, including business practices;
(3) Information relating to the views of principal owners, key members of the Board of Directors and client management on matters such as compliance with accounting standards and internal control environment;
(4) Are clients overly concerned with keeping audit fees as low as possible?
(5) Signs of inappropriate limitations on the scope of work of the auditing firm;
(6) Indications that the customer may be involved in money laundering or other illicit activities;
(7) Reasons for selecting the auditing firm and not reappointing the previous auditing firm;
(8) Names and identities of the parties involved.
The level of understanding of the auditing firm regarding the integrity of audited entityThe number of clients will increase as the auditing firm continues its relationship with them. audited entitythat customer.
A20. An auditing firm may obtain information about the integrity of its client by:
(1) Communicate with the client's previous or current accounting service provider in accordance with relevant professional standards and ethical regulations, and discuss with other third parties;
(2) Interview other officers and employees of the auditing firm or third parties such as banks, lawyers and companies in the same field as the client;
(3) Search for relevant databases.
Maintaining customer relationships (Guidance in paragraph 27(a) of this Standard)
A21. When deciding whether to maintain a client relationship, an audit firm should consider significant issues arising during the performance of the current or prior service contract and the impact of these issues on maintaining the client relationship. For example, a client may begin expanding its business into a new area for which the audit firm lacks the necessary expertise.
Withdrawal from service contract(as per guidance in paragraph 28 of this Standard)
A22. Policies and procedures regarding withdrawal from service contracts or withdrawal from service contracts and termination of customer relationships should specify the following:
(1) Discuss with members at the appropriate level of the client's Board of Directors and management team about actions the audit firm may take in accordance with the specific facts and circumstances;
(2) Discuss with members at the appropriate level of the client's Board of Directors and management about withdrawal from the service contract or withdrawal from the service contract and termination of the client relationship and the reasons for withdrawal from the service contract, if the audit firm determines such withdrawal is necessary;
(3) Consider whether there are professional standards, laws and regulations requiring the audit firm to continue performing the contract or to report the withdrawal from the service contract or both the withdrawal from the service contract and the termination of the client relationship, along with the reasons for the withdrawal from the service contract to the competent State authorities;
(4) Keep in documents and records important issues, consultation results, conclusions and the basis of those conclusions.
Note for auditing firms performing audits in the public sector. (Refer to paragraphs 26-28 of this Standard)
A23. By law, auditors may be appointed to perform audits in the public sector. Therefore, some requirements and considerations relating to the acceptance and maintenance of client relationships and specific contracts as prescribed in paragraphs 26-28 and guidance in paragraphs A18-A22 of this Standard may not be appropriate. However, the development of policies and procedures as guided in paragraphs A18-A22 of this Standard may provide public sector auditors with valuable information for assessing risk and fulfilling reporting responsibilities.
Human resources (Guidance in paragraph 29 of this Standard)
A24. Examples of human resource policies and procedures of an auditing firm include:
(1) Recruitment;
(2) Evaluating work performance;
(3) Ability, including time to perform assigned tasks;
(4) Professional competence;
(5) Career development;
(6) Opportunities for promotion;
(7) Salary;
(8) Estimate the needs of officers and employees.
Effective recruitment processes and procedures help audit firms select individuals with integrity who have the professional development and skills necessary to perform the firm's work and possess the qualities needed to excel at their job.
A25. Professional competence can be enhanced through various methods, including:
(1) Professional training;
(2) Regularly update knowledge, including training;
(3) Work experience;
(4) Guided by more experienced staff, e.g., other members of the service contract team;
(5) Training on independence for all officers and staff required to adhere to independence.
A26. Maintaining the professional competence of audit firm staff depends significantly on the level of regular knowledge updates to help staff maintain their knowledge and capabilities. Effective policies and procedures emphasize the need for ongoing training for all levels of audit firm staff and allocate the necessary resources and support for training to help all audit firm staff maintain and enhance their professional competence and capabilities.
A27. An auditing firm may utilize individuals outside the auditing firm who possess appropriate professional competence, for example, when the auditing firm lacks the necessary professional resources and training.
A28. Performance evaluation procedures, salary assessments, and promotion opportunities within audit firms demonstrate recognition and appropriate rewards for maintaining and enhancing professional competence and commitment to ethical principles. Steps that audit firms can take to maintain and enhance professional competence and commitment to ethical principles include:
(1) Inform all officers and staff about the audit firm's expectations regarding work performance and professional ethical principles;
(2) Guidance for officers and employees on evaluating work performance, progress and career development;
(3) Help officers and staff understand that promotion to higher positions depends on work performance and adherence to professional ethical principles and understand that they may be disciplined if they do not comply with the audit firm's policies and procedures.
Note for small auditing firms
A29. The size and circumstances of an audit firm will influence the structure of its performance evaluation process. In particular, smaller audit firms may use non-standardized methods to evaluate the performance of their staff.
Assigning teams to execute service contracts.
Board member responsible for overall service contract (guidance in paragraph 30 of this Standard)
A30. Policies and procedures may include workload and time monitoring systems to ensure that members of the Board of Directors responsible for the overall service contract fulfill their responsibilities.
Service Contract Performance Group (guidance in paragraph 31 of this Standard)
A31. When assigning a team to perform a service contract and determining the required level of supervision, examples of things that an audit firm needs to consider regarding the service contract team include:
(1) Understanding and practical experience of service contracts of similar nature and complexity through appropriate guidance, training and participation;
(2) Understanding of professional standards, laws and relevant regulations;
(3) Professional knowledge, including knowledge of relevant information technology;
(4) Knowledge of the customer's occupations and fields of activity;
(5) Ability to apply professional judgments;
(6) Understanding of the audit firm's quality control policies and procedures.
Execute the service contract
Consistency in the quality of service contract performance. (Guidance in paragraph 32(a) of this Standard)
A32. An audit firm emphasizes consistency in the quality of service performance through its audit firm policies and procedures. These policies and procedures are typically disseminated through written or electronic guidance documents, software tools or other document templates, and issue-specific guidance documents. Issues covered by guidance may include:
(1) The service contract team is instructed so that they can understand the work objectives of the contract;
(2) Procedures to ensure compliance with relevant professional standards;
(3) Procedures for monitoring the implementation of service contracts, training and guiding staff;
(4) Methods of review of work performed, significant judgments and reports issued;
(5) Keep in documents and records of the service contract the results of the work performed, the schedule and scope of review;
(6) Processes for updating and disseminating all policies and procedures.
A33. Appropriate training and teamwork will help less experienced members of the service contract team understand the assigned work objectives.
Monitor (Guidance in paragraph 32(b) of this Standard)
A34. Monitoring of service contracts includes:
(1) Monitoring the progress of the service contract;
(2) Consider the professional competence and capabilities of each member of the service contract team to see if they have sufficient time to perform the work, whether they understand the instructions, and whether the work is carried out according to the method in the service contract implementation plan;
(3) Address important issues arising during the service contract execution, consider the importance of those issues and adjust the plan accordingly;
(4) Identify issues that require consultation or consideration by more experienced members of the service contract team during the contract execution process.
Review (Guidance in paragraph 32(c) of this Standard)
A35. Issues requiring review include:
(1) Whether the work is performed in accordance with professional standards, laws and relevant regulations;
(2) Are important issues raised for further consideration?
(3) Whether appropriate consultation has been conducted and whether the consultation results have been documented and implemented;
(4) Is it necessary to adjust the content, schedule and scope of work performed?
(5) Does the work performed support the conclusions drawn and is it properly documented in records?
(6) Have sufficient appropriate evidence been collected to form the basis for issuing the report?
(7) Have the objectives of the service contract procedures been achieved?
Consult with a consultant.(as per guidance in paragraph 34 of this Standard)
A36. Consulting involves discussions with individuals of appropriate expertise inside or outside the auditing firm.
A37. Consulting with consultants utilizes appropriate research resources as well as the collective experience and professional skills of the audit firm. Consulting with consultants helps improve the quality and usability of professional judgment. Appropriate regulations regarding consulting with consultants in the audit firm's policies and procedures promote a corporate culture that recognizes consulting with consultants. considered a useful tool and encourage officers and staff to seek advice on complex or potentially contentious issues.
A38. Consulting on professional, ethical, and other important matters within or outside the audit firm, if necessary, can be effective when the consulting professionals:
(1) Provided with all relevant information so that they can give appropriate advice;
(2) Having relevant knowledge, seniority and experience.
At the same time, the results of the consultation must be documented and implemented appropriately.
A39. The thorough and detailed documentation of expert consultations on complex or contentious issues will help to understand:
(1) Issues requiring consultation;
(2) Consultation results, including decisions made, the basis and methods for implementing those decisions.
Note for small auditing firms
A40. Audit firms that need to seek external advice, for example when they lack appropriate internal resources, may utilize consulting services provided by:
(1) Other auditing firms;
(2) Professional organizations or state agencies; or
(3) Commercial organizations provide appropriate quality control services.
Before contracting for such services, auditing firms need to assess the expertise and capabilities of the external service provider to determine whether that organization has the appropriate qualifications for advisory services.
Reviewing the quality control of service contracts
Criteria for reviewing the quality control of service contracts (guidance in paragraph 35(b) of this Standard)
A41. Criteria for determining which service contracts other than the audit of financial statements of listed organizations require quality control review may include:
(1) Content of the service contract, including the extent to which it relates to public interest;
(2) Identify unusual situations or risks in a service contract or group of service contracts;
(3) Do laws and regulations require a review of the quality control of service contracts?
Content, schedule, and scope of the review of quality control for service contracts (guidance in paragraphs 36-37 of this Standard)
A42. Service contract reports shall not be dated before the completion of the service contract quality control review. However, the retention of documentation and records regarding the service contract quality control review may be completed after the date of the service contract report.
A43. Conducting quality control reviews of service contracts at appropriate times during the contract execution process allows for the timely and satisfactory resolution of significant issues on or before the date of the service contract report.
A44. The scope of a quality control review of a service contract may depend on the complexity of the service contract, whether the client is a listed entity, and the risk that the service contract report may not be appropriate to the specific circumstances. Performing a quality control review of a service contract does not diminish the responsibility of the Board member responsible for the overall service contract.
Review of quality control of service contracts for listed organizations (guidance in paragraph 38 of this Standard)
A45. When reviewing the quality control of the financial statement audit of a listed organization, issues related to the assessment of the audit team's material judgments that may be considered include:
(1) Significant risks discovered during the performance of the contract and measures to address those risks;
(2) The judgments made, in particular judgments of materiality and significant risks;
(3) The importance and trend of errors that have been and have not been corrected detected during the performance of the contract;
(4) Issues must be discussed with the Board of Directors and the management of the audited entity and other parties such as state management agencies, if necessary.
The issues mentioned above depend on the specific circumstances and may also apply to the quality control review of financial statement audits of other entities, as well as to financial statement review services, assurance services, and other related services.
Note for auditing firms conduct audit in the public sector
A46. Although not listed entities as described in paragraph A16 of this Standard, some entities in the public sector may be critical enough to require performance of quality control reviews of service contracts.
Criteria for the competence of reviewers in the quality control of service contracts.
Possesses the appropriate professional skills, experience and authority (guidance in paragraph 39(a) of this Standard).
A47. Determining whether the quality control reviewer for a service contract possesses the appropriate professional skills, experience, and authority depends on the specific circumstances of the service contract. For example, the quality control reviewer for an audit of a listed entity's financial statements may be an individual with the appropriate experience and authority to serve as a member of the Board of Directors responsible for the overall audit of the listed entity's financial statements.
Consult with the reviewer regarding the quality control of the service contract (guidance in paragraph 39(b) of this Standard).
A48. During the execution of a service contract, the member of the Board of Directors responsible for the overall service contract may consult with the service contract quality control reviewer to ensure that the judgment of the member of the Board of Directors responsible for the overall service contract will be accepted by the service contract quality control reviewer. The purpose of consulting is to avoid differences of opinion arising at the end of the service contract and not to affect the ability of the service contract quality control reviewer to perform their role. When the content and scope of the consultation are substantial, the objectivity of the service contract quality control reviewer may be reduced, unless both the service contract team and the reviewer pay attention to maintaining the reviewer's objectivity. If this is not possible Maintain the objectivity of the reviewer.Alternatively, another individual within the auditing firm or an individual outside the auditing firm with appropriate qualifications may be appointed as the reviewer of the quality control of the service contract or as the consultant for the service contract.
Objectivity of the reviewer in the quality control of service contracts (guidance in paragraph 40 of this Standard)
A49. Audit firms must establish policies and procedures to maintain the objectivity of the reviewers of service quality control, which shall specify who the reviewers of service quality control shall be:
(1) Not selected by the Board member in charge of the overall service contract;
(2) Not participating in the service contract during the review period;
(3) Do not make decisions on behalf of the service contract team;
(4) Not affected by other issues that could threaten the objectivity of the reviewer.
Note for small auditing firms
A50. For audit firms with few members of the Board of Directors, it may be difficult to avoid the Board member responsible for the overall service contract participating in the selection of the person reviewing the quality control of the service contract. Smaller audit firms may hire qualified external individuals. to conduct a review of the quality control of the service contract. If it is determined that a service contract requires a quality control review, some smaller audit firms may also use other audit firms to perform the quality control review of the service contract. If the audit firm hires qualified external individuals, the provisions of paragraphs 39-41 and the guidance in paragraphs A47-A48 of this Standard shall apply.
Note for those of enterprise audit conduct audit in the public sector
A51. In the public sector, where an auditor is appointed to conduct a mandatory audit (for example, the State Auditor General commissions or hires an auditor) auditing firm If the person is qualified to conduct the audit on behalf of the State Auditor General, the person entrusted or hired may hold a role equivalent to that of a member of the Board of Directors in charge of the overall audit in the public sector. In that case, the selection of the person reviewing the quality control of the audit may require consideration of the need for independence from the audited entity and the ability of the reviewer to provide an objective assessment of the audit quality control.
Differences in perspective (Refer to paragraph 43 of this Standard)
A52. Effective procedures will help identify differences in opinion at an early stage. of the service contract execution processThis includes providing clear instructions on the next steps to be taken, requiring documentation and record-keeping of measures taken to resolve differences of opinion and the implementation of the conclusions reached.
A53. Procedures for resolving differences of opinion may include consulting with another auditor or auditing firm, or a professional organization or government regulatory body.
Documents and records related to service contracts.
Complete the formal documentation of the service contract (guidance in paragraph 45 of this Standard)
A54. Laws and regulations may specify a time limit for completing the formal documentation of a service contract for certain specific service contracts. Where laws and regulations do not specify such a time limit, paragraph 45 of this Standard shall provide for the audit firm to state the necessary time limit for completing the formal documentation of the service contract. For example, for an audit engagement, that time limit is typically no more than 60 days after the date of the audit report.
A55. When two or more separate reports are issued on the same matter concerning an entity, the audit firm's policies and procedures regarding the deadline for completing the formal documentation of the service contract for each report shall be applied as to each separate service contract. For example, this may occur when an audit firm issues an audit report on the financial statements of a subsidiary for the purpose of preparing the consolidated financial statements of the group and then issues another audit report on the same financial statements as required by law.
Confidentiality, security, integrity, accessibility, and recoverability of service contract documents and records (guidance in paragraph 46 of this Standard)
A56. Relevant professional ethical standards and regulations require audit firm officers and employees to respect the confidentiality of information contained in service contract documents and records, unless the client permits disclosure, or law or professional obligation requires them to disclose the information. Law and specific regulations may require other obligations of audit firm officers and employees relating to maintaining client confidentiality, particularly with respect to personal information.
A57. Whether the documentation or records concerning service contracts are in paper, electronic, or other forms, the integrity, accessibility, and recoverability of the data may not be guaranteed if the documentation or records are altered, supplemented, or deleted without the audit firm's knowledge, or if the documentation or records are lost or permanently damaged. Therefore, to prevent the possibility of unauthorized alteration or loss of documentation or records concerning service contracts, the audit firm may design and implement controls including:
(1) Controls allow for the identification of when and who creates, modifies or reviews documents and records related to service contracts;
(2) Controls protect the integrity of information at all stages of the service contract, especially when information is shared within the service contract team or transferred to other parties via the Internet;
(3) Controls aimed at preventing unauthorized changes to service contract documents and records;
(4) Controls allow the service contract team and other authorized parties to access service contract documents and records as needed to complete their tasks.
A58. To maintain the confidentiality, security, integrity, accessibility, and recoverability of service contract documents and records, the audit firm may design and implement controls including:
(1) Use passwords for members of the service contract team to prevent unauthorized users from accessing service contract documents and records;
(2) Appropriate backup procedures for electronic documents and records of service contracts at appropriate stages during the service contract execution process;
(3) Procedures for distributing documents and files on service contracts to members of the contract execution team at the start of contract execution, processing documents and files during contract execution, and comparing documents and files at the end of the contract;
(4) Procedures to restrict access and allow reasonable distribution and secure storage of hard copies of service contract documents and records.
A59. In practice, original documents and records may be converted into electronic versions for inclusion in the service contract file. In that case, to maintain the integrity, accessibility, and recoverability of the service contract documents and records, the audit firm's procedures may require the service contract group to:
(1) Create a scanned copy in electronic form that fully reflects the content of the original paper document or record, including handwritten signatures, references and notes;
(2) Include this electronic document in the service contract file, including the table of contents, and sign these electronic copies if necessary;
(3) Allow these electronic documents to be recovered and printed when needed.
Laws and other regulations may require auditing firms to retain paper copies of original documents and records that have been converted into electronic form.
Documentation and record keeping regarding service contracts (guidance in paragraph 47 of this Standard)
A60. The necessity of retaining documentation and records of service contracts and the retention period will vary depending on the content of the service contract and the specific circumstances of the audit firm, for example, whether documentation and records of the service contract are necessary to provide evidence of issues continuing to affect future service contracts. The retention period may also depend on other factors, such as whether national laws and regulations require specific retention periods for certain types of service contracts, or whether there is a general practice regarding retention periods if national laws and regulations do not require such periods.
A61. For audit contracts, the minimum record retention period is 10 years calculated from the date of the audit report, or from the date of the group audit report (if any).
A62. Examples of procedures used by audit firms for the retention of documents and records relating to service contracts, including procedures that allow compliance with the requirements of paragraph 47 of this Standard during the retention period, include:
(1) Allows for the recovery and access of service contract documents and records during the storage period, especially for electronic documents and records, as technology may be upgraded or changed over time;
(2) Provide evidence of changes made to the service contract documents and records after the service contract records have been completed, if necessary;
(3) Allowing authorized external parties to access and review certain documents and records related to specific service contracts for quality control or other purposes.
Ownership rights to documents and records related to service contracts.
A63. Documents and records relating to service contracts are the property of the auditing firm, unless otherwise provided by law. The auditing firm may distribute or extract documents and records relating to service contracts to provide to clients, provided that such disclosure does not diminish the validity of the work performed, or the independence of the auditing firm or its officers and employees in the case of performing assurance service contracts.
Monitor
Monitoring the quality control policies and procedures of the auditing firm. (Refer to paragraph 48 of this Standard)
A64. The purpose of monitoring compliance with quality control policies and procedures is to assess:
(1) Compliance with professional standards, laws and relevant regulations;
(2) Whether the quality control system is properly designed and effectively implemented;
(3) Whether the audit firm's quality control policies and procedures are appropriately applied to ensure that the reports issued by the audit firm are appropriate to the specific circumstances.
A65. Continuous review and evaluation of the quality control system includes the following:
(1) Analysis:
– Changes in professional standards, laws, and related regulations, and how those changes are reflected in the audit firm's policies and procedures where appropriate;
– Provide written confirmation of compliance with policies and procedures regarding independence;
– Regularly update professional knowledge, including training;
– Decisions related to accepting and maintaining customer relationships and specific service contracts.
(2) Identify corrective and improvement measures to be taken for the system, including providing feedback on audit firm policies and procedures related to training;
(3) Discuss with relevant officers and staff about identified weaknesses in the system, the level of understanding of the system, or compliance with the system;
(4) Monitoring by relevant officers and staff of the audit firm to make timely necessary adjustments to quality control policies and procedures.
A66. Policies and procedures for periodic inspections may be implemented every three years. The organization of periodic inspections, including the scheduling of each audit, depends on several factors, including:
(1) The size of the auditing firm;
(2) Number and geographical location of offices;
(3) Previous test results;
(4) Authority of officers, staff and offices (for example, whether offices have the right to conduct inspections themselves or only the head office has the right to conduct inspections);
(5) Content and complexity in the organizational structure and operation of the auditing firm;
(6) Risks related to clients and specific service contracts of the audit firm.
A67. The audit process involves selecting separate service contracts, some of which may be selected without prior notice to the service contract team. When determining the scope of the audit, the audit firm may consider the scope or conclusions of an independent external audit program. However, an independent external audit program cannot serve as a substitute for the audit firm's internal oversight program.
Note for small auditing firms
A68. For small audit firms, supervisory procedures may need to be performed by individuals responsible for designing and implementing the audit firm's quality control procedures and policies, or by individuals who may be involved in the quality control review of the service contract. Smaller audit firms may choose to select qualified external individuals or another audit firm to perform the service contract review and other supervisory procedures. The audit firm may also agree to combine the use of resources with other appropriate organizations to conduct supervisory activities.
Discussing shortcomings (Refer to paragraph 50 of this Standard)
A69. When communicating about deficiencies discovered with individuals other than the Board of Directors responsible for the overall service contract, the audit firm does not need to identify which specific service contract those deficiencies belong to, although such identification may be necessary for the individuals other than the Board of Directors responsible for the overall service contract to fulfill their responsibilities effectively.
Complaints and accusations
Sources of complaints and allegations (guidance in paragraph 55 of this Standard)
A70. Complaints and allegations (excluding minor complaints and allegations) may originate from within or outside the audit firm. Complaints and allegations may be from audit firm officers and employees, clients, or other third parties. Such complaints and allegations may be received by members of the service team or other officers and employees of the audit firm.
Investigation policies and procedures (guidance in paragraph 56 of this Standard)
A71. Policies and procedures established for investigating complaints and allegations may include provisions such as requiring the Board member overseeing the investigation to:
(1) Have sufficient relevant experience;
(2) Having authority in the auditing firm;
(3) Not participating in the service contract.
Members of the Board of Directors overseeing the investigation may seek the advice of legal counsel if necessary.
Note for small auditing firms
A72. For audit firms with few members of the Board of Directors, it may be difficult to avoid a Board member overseeing the investigation being involved in the service contract. Smaller audit firms may use qualified external individuals or another audit firm to conduct investigations into complaints and allegations.
Documents and records related to the quality control system. (Refer to paragraph 57 of this Standard)
A73. The form and content of documents and records serving as evidence of the operation of each element in the quality control system is a matter of judgment and depends on several factors, including:
(1) Size of the auditing firm and number of offices;
(2) Content and complexity in the organizational structure and operation of the auditing firm.
For example, large auditing firms may use electronic databases to record issues such as confirmations of independence, performance reviews, and supervisory audit results.
A74. Relevant documents and records related to supervision include:
(1) Monitoring procedures, including procedures for selecting completed service contracts for inspection;
(2) Evaluation records on:
– Adherence to professional standards, laws, and relevant regulations;
– Is the quality control system properly designed and effectively implemented?
– Are the audit firm's quality control policies and procedures appropriately applied, ensuring that the reports issued by the audit firm are suitable for the specific circumstances?
(3) Identify the detected deficiencies, assess the impact of those deficiencies and the basis for determining whether further action is needed and, if so, what that action should be.
Note for small auditing firms
A75. Small audit firms may use informal methods in documentation and records regarding their quality control systems, such as notes, questionnaires, and forms.
*****