VIETNAMESE AUDITING STANDARDS SYSTEM
Auditing Standard 720: Other information in documents containing audited financial statements
(Issued together with Circular No. 214/2012/TT-BTC) (December 6, 2012, Ministry of Finance)
I/ General Regulations
Scope of application
1. This auditing standard specifies and guides the responsibilities of auditors. and auditing firms (hereinafter referred to as "auditors") This relates to other information contained in the audited financial statements and the audit report. Unless otherwise specifically required in the audit engagement, the auditor is not required to express an opinion on other information, nor is the auditor responsible for determining whether other information in the audited financial statements has been properly presented. However, the auditor should consider this other information because the reliability of the audited financial statements may be compromised due to the possibility of material inconsistencies between the audited financial statements and this other information (see guidance in paragraph A1 of this Standard).
2. In this Standard, “Audited financial statement documents” means annual reports (or similar documents) issued to owners. (or third parties such as banks, suppliers, customers, tax authorities, prospective investors, etc.)This includes audited financial statements and accompanying audit reports. This standard may also be applied to other documents such as information disclosures when issuing securities. (prospectus) as prescribed in paragraph 2 of Vietnamese Auditing Standard No. 200 (see guidance in paragraph A02 of this Standard).
3. Auditors and audit firms must comply with the provisions and guidance of this Standard during the audit process.
The audited entity (client) and the parties using the audit results must have the necessary understanding of the regulations and guidance of this Standard in order to coordinate work with the auditor and the audit firm in handling the relationships related to the audit process.
Target
4. Auditor and auditing firms Appropriate measures must be taken in cases where documents containing audited financial statements and audit reports also contain other information that may reduce the reliability of the financial statements and audit reports.
Terminology explained
5. In Vietnamese auditing standards, the following terms are understood as follows:
(a) Other information: Financial or non-financial information (outside of the financial statements and audit report) that, by law or practice, is presented in the documentation containing the financial statements and audit report (see guidance in paragraphs A3–A4 of this Standard);
(b) Inconsistencies: These are discrepancies between information other than that in the audited financial statements. Material inconsistencies may cast doubt on the audit conclusions based on the audit evidence gathered and may also cast doubt on the basis for the auditor's opinion on the financial statements;
(c) Misleading information: This refers to other information unrelated to the matters stated in the audited financial statements, and which is presented or disclosed inaccurately. Material misinformation may reduce the reliability of the audited financial statements.
II/ Standard Content
Requirement
Consider other information
6. The auditor must consider other information to identify any material inconsistencies with the audited financial statements (if any).
7. The auditor must take appropriate steps to approach the management or administration of the audited entity to obtain other information before the date of the audit report. If other information cannot be obtained before the date of the audit report, the auditor should consider obtaining other information as soon as possible (see guidance in paragraph A5 of this Standard).
Key inconsistencies
8. When considering other information, if the auditor discovers material inconsistencies, the auditor must determine whether it is necessary to amend the audited financial statements or amend other information.
Significant inconsistencies are identified in other information gathered prior to the date of the audit report.
9. If amendments to the audited financial statements are necessary but the management of the audited entity does not accept the amendments, the auditor must issue an audit opinion other than an unqualified opinion, in accordance with the provisions and guidance of Vietnamese Auditing Standard No. 705.
10. If amendments to other information are necessary but the Board of Directors of the audited entity does not accept the amendments, the auditor must discuss this matter with the Board of Directors (unless all members of the Board of Directors are also members of the Board of Management) as required by paragraph 13 of Vietnamese Auditing Standard No. 260, and:
(a) Present in the audit report a “Other Matters” section describing material inconsistencies as required by paragraph 08 of Vietnamese Auditing Standard 706; or
(b) Failure to issue an audit report; or
(c) Withdrawal from the audit engagement – if permitted by law and regulations (see guidance in paragraphs A6–A7 of this Standard).
Significant inconsistencies are identified in other information gathered after the audit report date.
11. If corrections to audited financial statements are necessary, the auditor shall comply with the relevant provisions in paragraphs 10–17 of Vietnamese Auditing Standard No. 560.
12. If further modifications to information are necessary and the management of the audited entity agrees to the modifications, the auditor must perform additional necessary procedures as required in each case (see guidance in paragraph A8 of this Standard).
13. If corrections to other information are necessary but the management of the audited entity does not agree to the corrections, the auditor must inform the management of the auditor's observations regarding the other information (unless all members of the management are also members of the board of directors) and take further appropriate measures (see guidance in paragraph A9 of this Standard).
Material misinformation
14. When considering other information to identify material inconsistencies, if material misinformation is discovered, the auditor must discuss this matter with the management of the audited entity (see guidance in paragraph A10 of this Standard).
15. After consultation, if deemed unsatisfactory, the auditor must request the Board of Directors of the audited entity to consult with a qualified third party, such as the entity's legal counsel, and the auditor must consider these opinions.
16. If the auditor concludes that there is a material misstatement in other information but the management of the audited entity does not accept the correction, the auditor must notify the management of the auditor's observations regarding the other information (unless all members of the management are also members of the board of directors) and take further appropriate measures (see guidance in paragraph A11 of this Standard).
III/ Application Instructions
When implementing this Standard, reference should be made to Vietnamese Auditing Standard No. 200.
Scope of application
Additional responsibilities as required by law and regulations regarding other information. (Guidance in paragraph 01 of this Standard)
A1. As required by law and regulations, auditors may have additional responsibilities regarding information not covered by this Standard. For example, the law may require auditors to perform procedures to identify additional information such as mandatory supplemental data or to express an opinion on the reliability of indicators presented in other information. When such obligations exist, the auditor's additional responsibilities are determined by the nature of the audit or by law, regulations, and professional ethical standards. If such additional information is omitted or misrepresented, the auditor may be required to state this in the audit report as required by law and other regulations.
The document contains audited financial statements. (Guidance in paragraph 02 of this Standard)
Notes on auditing small entities
A2. Unless required by law or regulations, small entities typically do not issue audited financial statements. However, laws and regulations may require the management of the audited entity to prepare audited financial statements. Examples of other information included in audited financial statements of small entities are detailed profit and loss statements and management accounting reports.
Definition of other information (Guidance in paragraph 05(a) of this Standard)
A3. Other information may include:
(1) Report of the Board of Directors or the Board of Management of the audited entity on the activities of the entity;
(2) Summary of financial information or notes;
(3) Information about personnel;
(4) Capital utilization plan;
(5) Financial indicators;
(6) List of key personnel (Board of Directors, Management Board…);
(7) Other selected information.
A4. According to Vietnamese auditing standards, other information not included:
(1) An article or notice, such as a letter of introduction accompanied by documents containing audited financial statements and audit report;
(2) Information contained in analyses and guidelines;
(3) Information on the websites of the audited entity ((excluding the Annual Report).
Consider other information (Guidance in paragraph 07 of this Standard)
A5. Gathering additional information prior to the audit report date allows the auditor to address material inconsistencies and material misinformation in a timely manner with the management of the audited entity. The auditor and the management of the audited entity should agree on the timely notification of additional information to the auditor as soon as it arises.
Key inconsistencies
Significant inconsistencies are identified in other information gathered prior to the date of the audit report. (Guidance in paragraph 10 of this Standard)
A6. If the management of the audited entity does not accept the amendment of other information, the auditor may consider the need to take additional measures on the basis of legal counsel's advice.
Notes on auditing public sector entities
A7. When auditing entities in the public sector, auditors may not be permitted to withdraw from the audit engagement or to withhold the audit report. In such cases, the auditor may submit a report to the appropriate authority to present the material inconsistencies.
Significant inconsistencies are identified in other information gathered after the audit report date. (Refer to paragraphs 12-13 of this Standard)
A8. If the management of the audited entity agrees to amend other information, the auditor may take steps, including reviewing the work of the management of the audited entity to ensure that those who received the financial statements, previously issued audit reports and other information have been fully informed of the amendment.
A9. If further modification of information is necessary but the management of the audited entity does not agree to the modification, the auditor should take further appropriate measures, such as consulting with legal counsel.
Material misinformation (Refer to paragraphs 14-16 of this Standard)
A10. When discussing material misinformation with the management of the audited entity, the auditor may still be unable to assess the accuracy of certain disclosures in other information and the management's responses to the auditor's questions, and the auditor may conclude that there are certainly differences in judgment or opinion between the auditor and the management of the audited entity.
A11. If the auditor concludes that there is material misinformation but the management of the audited entity refuses to correct it, the auditor should take further appropriate measures, such as consulting with legal counsel.
*****