VIETNAMESE AUDITING STANDARDS SYSTEM
Auditing Standard 330: The Auditor's Remedies for Assessed Risks
(Issued together with Circular No. 214/2012/TT-BTC) (December 6, 2012, Ministry of Finance)
I/ General Regulations
Scope of application
1. This auditing standard specifies and guides the responsibilities of auditors. and auditing firms (hereinafter referred to as "auditor") in designing and implementing measures to address material misstatement risks that auditors have identified and assessed during the audit of financial statements in accordance with Vietnamese Auditing Standard No. 315.
2. Auditors and audit firms (hereinafter referred to as “auditors”) must comply with the provisions and guidance of this Standard in the performance of auditing financial statements.
The audited entity (client) and the parties using the audit results must have the necessary understanding of the regulations and guidance of this Standard in order to coordinate work with the auditor and the audit firm, as well as to manage relationships related to the audited information.
Target
3. Objectives of the auditor and auditing firms This involves gathering sufficient appropriate audit evidence relating to the assessed risks of material misstatement, through the design and implementation of appropriate remedies for these risks.
Terminology explained
4. In Vietnamese auditing standards, the following terms are understood as follows:
(a) Substantive testing: An audit procedure designed to detect material misstatements at the assertion level. Substantive tests include:
(i) Detailed examination (transaction groups, account balances and explanatory information);
(ii) Basic analysis procedures.
(b) Control testing: An audit procedure designed to assess the effectiveness of controls in preventing, or detecting and correcting, material misstatements at the assertion level.
II/ Standard Content
Requirement
Overall remedial measures
5. Auditors must design and implement comprehensive measures to address risks of material misstatement that have been assessed at the financial statement level (see guidance in paragraphs A1–A3 of this Standard).
Audit procedures for the risk of material misstatement have been assessed at the assertion level.
6. The auditor shall design and perform subsequent audit procedures with the content, timing, and scope based on the assessment of the risk of material misstatement at the assertion level (see guidance in paragraphs A4–A8 of this Standard).
7. When designing subsequent audit procedures, the auditor must:
(a) Consider the reasons for assessing the risk of material misstatement at the assertion level for each group of transactions, account balances and disclosures, including:
(i) The possibility of material misstatement due to the specific characteristics of the transaction groups, account balances, or related disclosures (inherent risk);
(ii) Whether the risk assessment takes into account relevant controls (control risk), and if so, whether the auditor must obtain audit evidence to determine whether the controls are functioning effectively (meaning: the auditor intends to rely on the effectiveness of the controls to determine the nature, timing and scope of substantive tests) (see guidance in paragraphs A9–A18 of this Standard);
(b) The higher the level of risk assessed by the auditor, the more compelling audit evidence must be obtained (see guidance in paragraph A19 of this Standard).
Control experiment
8. Auditors must design and perform control tests to obtain sufficient appropriate audit evidence regarding the effectiveness of the relevant control if:
(a) When assessing the risk of material misstatement at the assertion level, the auditor expects that operational controls are effective (i.e., the auditor intends to rely on the effectiveness of the control to determine the nature, timing, and scope of substantive testing); or
(b) Performing only substantive tests may not provide sufficient appropriate audit evidence at the assertion level (see guidance in paragraphs A20–A24 of this Standard).
9. When designing and conducting control tests, the more confident the auditor is in the effectiveness of the control, the more compelling audit evidence should be obtained (see guidance in paragraph A25 of this Standard).
Content and scope of the control test
10. When designing and conducting control tests, auditors must:
(a) Perform other audit procedures in conjunction with the interview procedure to gather audit evidence regarding the effectiveness of the control activities, including:
(i) How controls were implemented at the relevant times during the audited period;
(ii) Whether controls are implemented consistently;
(iii) Who performs the controls and how they are performed (see guidance in paragraphs A26–A29 of this Standard)
(b) Determine whether the controls being tested are dependent on other controls (indirect controls) and, if so, whether it is necessary to gather audit evidence demonstrating the effectiveness of those indirect controls (see guidance in paragraphs A30–A31 of this Standard).
Controlled testing schedule
11. The auditor shall perform control testing for a particular point in time, or for the entire period during which the auditor intends to rely on those controls, as prescribed in paragraphs 12 and 15 below, in order to provide a suitable basis for the auditor's confidence in those controls (see guidance in paragraph A32 of this Standard).
Utilize audit evidence gathered during the interim period.
12. If the auditor obtains audit evidence regarding the effectiveness of controls during the interim period, the auditor must:
(a) Gather audit evidence regarding significant changes in controls that occur after the interim period;
(b) Determine additional audit evidence to be gathered for the remaining period (see guidance in paragraphs A33–A34 of this Standard).
Utilize audit evidence gathered from previous audits.
13. To determine whether the use of audit evidence regarding the effectiveness of controls from previous audits is appropriate, and to determine the time period before re-testing controls, the auditor must consider the following:
(a) The effectiveness of other components of internal control, including the control environment, the monitoring of controls, and the entity's risk assessment process;
(b) Risks arising from the characteristics of the control, whether that control is performed manually or automatically;
(c) The effectiveness of general controls on information technology;
(d) The effectiveness of the controls and the implementation of those controls by the entity, including the nature and extent of deviations in the implementation of controls noted in previous audits, and whether any personnel changes have significantly affected the implementation of those controls;
(e) Does not changing a particular control pose a risk when circumstances have changed?
(f) Risk of material misstatement and level of confidence in controls (see guidance in paragraph A35 of this Standard).
14. If the auditor intends to use audit evidence regarding the effectiveness of a specific control obtained from a prior audit, the auditor must demonstrate that such evidence remains valid by obtaining audit evidence of whether significant changes have occurred in those controls since the prior audit. The auditor must obtain this evidence by conducting interviews combined with observation or investigation, to confirm an understanding of those specific controls, and:
(a) If there are changes affecting the appropriateness of audit evidence gathered from a prior audit, the auditor must perform control testing in the current audit (see guidance in paragraph A36 of this Standard);
(b) Unless otherwise stated, the auditor must perform control testing at least once in three consecutive audits, and must test some controls in each audit to avoid having to test all controls that the auditor intends to rely on in a single audit without testing any controls in the next two audits (see guidance in paragraphs A37–A39 of this Standard).
Controls for significant risks
15. If the auditor intends to rely on controls with respect to a risk that the auditor identifies as a significant risk, the auditor must test those controls during the current period.
Evaluating the effectiveness of control activities
16. When assessing the effectiveness of relevant controls, the auditor must evaluate whether errors discovered from substantive tests indicate that the controls are not functioning effectively. However, if substantive tests do not detect errors, it does not mean that the controls related to the assertion being tested are effective (see guidance in paragraph A40 of this Standard).
17. If deviations are discovered in controls that the auditor intends to rely on, the auditor must conduct specific interviews to learn about these issues and their potential consequences, and must determine (see guidance in paragraph A41 of this Standard):
(a) Do the control tests performed provide a suitable basis for the auditor to have confidence in those controls?
(b) Whether additional control tests are required; or
(c) Do potential risks of error need to be addressed by applying substantive testing?
Basic testing
18. Regardless of how material the risk assessment results may be, the auditor must design and perform substantive tests for each class of transactions, account balances, and material disclosures (see guidance in paragraphs A42–A47 of this Standard).
19. The auditor must consider whether external confirmation procedures such as substantive testing are necessary (see guidance in paragraphs A48–A51 of this Standard).
The basic testing involves the accounting closing process for preparing financial statements.
20. The auditor's substantive testing shall include audit procedures related to the closing of accounting books for the preparation of financial statements, as follows:
(a) Compare the figures in the financial statements with the figures in the accounting books;
(b) Examine material entries and other adjustments made in the preparation and presentation of financial statements (see guidance in paragraph A52 of this Standard).
Basic testing for significant risks
21. If the auditor has determined that the risk of material misstatement, assessed at the assertion level, is substantial, the auditor must perform substantive testing to address this risk. If substantive testing is performed only for a substantial risk, the substantive testing must include detailed testing (see guidance in paragraph A53 of this Standard).
Basic testing schedule
22. If substantive testing is performed at the time of the interim audit, in order to provide a reasonable basis for extending audit conclusions from the interim to the final period, the auditor must cover the remaining period by (see guidance in paragraphs A54–A57 of this Standard):
(a) Conduct substantive tests in conjunction with control tests for the mid-to-term period; or
(b) Perform additional substantive tests only if the auditor determines that they are sufficient.
23. When assessing the risk of material misstatement at the interim period, if unexpected misstatements are discovered, the auditor must assess whether an adjustment to the relevant risk assessment is necessary and whether adjustments to the content, timing, or scope of the substantive tests are required for the remaining period (see guidance in paragraph A58 of this Standard).
The completeness of the presentation and disclosure of financial statements.
24. The auditor must perform audit procedures to assess whether the overall presentation of the financial statements, including the relevant disclosures, is consistent with the applicable financial reporting framework (see guidance in paragraph A59 of this Standard).
Assessing the adequacy and appropriateness of audit evidence.
25. Based on the audit procedures performed and the audit evidence gathered, before drawing conclusions about the audit, the auditor must consider whether the assessment of the risk of material misstatement at the assertion level remains appropriate (see guidance in paragraphs A60-61 of this Standard).
26. The auditor must draw conclusions about the adequacy and appropriateness of the audit evidence gathered. When forming an audit opinion, the auditor must consider all relevant audit evidence, regardless of whether such evidence supports or contradicts the assertions of the financial statements (see guidance in paragraph A62 of this Standard).
27. If sufficient appropriate audit evidence has not been obtained relating to a material assertion in the financial statements, the auditor must endeavor to obtain additional audit evidence. If sufficient appropriate audit evidence cannot be obtained, the auditor must issue a qualified audit opinion or a disclaimer of opinion on the financial statements.
Audit documents and records
28. In accordance with paragraphs 08-11 and guidance in paragraph A6 of Vietnamese Auditing Standard 230, auditors must prepare and retain in their audit file:
(a) The overall treatment of material misstatement risks assessed at the financial reporting level and the content, timing, and scope of subsequent audit procedures performed;
(b) The relationship between those audit procedures and the risks assessed at the assertion level;
(c) Results of audit procedures, including conclusions, if those procedures are unclear (see guidance in paragraph A63 of this Standard).
29. If the auditor intends to use audit evidence regarding the effectiveness of controls obtained from previous audits, the auditor must record in the audit file conclusions based on confidence in the controls tested in the previous audit.
30. Audit documents and records must demonstrate that the figures in the financial statements have been reconciled with the figures in the accounting books.
III/ Application instructions
When implementing this Standard, reference should be made to Vietnamese Auditing Standard No. 200.
Overall remedial measures (Guidance in paragraph 05 of this Standard)
A1. Overall measures to address risks of material misstatement assessed in the financial statements may include:
(1) Emphasize to the audit team the need to maintain a professional skeptical attitude;
(2) Appointing audit team members with experience or special professional skills, or using experts;
(3) Strengthen supervision;
(4) Incorporate unpredictable factors when selecting the next audit procedures to be performed;
(5) Make general changes to the content, timing and scope of audit procedures, for example, perform substantive tests at the end of the period instead of mid-period, or change the content of audit procedures to obtain more convincing audit evidence.
A2. An auditor's understanding of the entity's control environment influences the assessment of the risk of material misstatement in the financial statements and therefore also influences the overall treatment. An effective control environment may allow the auditor to have greater confidence in internal controls and the reliability of audit evidence originating from within the entity, and thus allow the auditor to perform some audit procedures at the interim period instead of the end of the period. However, deficiencies in the control environment have the opposite effect; for example, the auditor may perform the following procedures in an ineffective control environment:
(1) Perform additional audit procedures at the end of the period instead of the middle of the period;
(2) Gather additional audit evidence from substantive tests;
(3) Expand the scope of the audit to more locations.
A3. Considering these issues significantly influences the auditor's overall approach, for example, focusing on substantive testing (substantive method) or a combination of control testing with substantive testing (combined method).
Audit procedures for the risk of material misstatement have been assessed at the assertion level.
Content, schedule, and scope of subsequent audit procedures. (Guidance in paragraph 06 of this Standard)
A4. The auditor's assessment of the risks identified at the assertion level provides the basis for selecting appropriate audit methods to design and perform subsequent audit procedures. For example, the auditor may determine that:
(a) By performing control tests alone, the auditor can take effective action to address the assessed risk of material misstatement for a particular assertion;
(b) Only substantive testing is appropriate for specific assertions, thus the auditor overlooks the effect of controls when assessing related risks. This oversight may result from the auditor’s risk assessment procedures failing to identify any effective controls relevant to the assertions, or from the ineffective testing of controls, leading the auditor to not intend to rely on the effectiveness of the controls to determine the nature, timing, and scope of substantive testing; or
(c) The combined approach of control testing and baseline testing is an effective method.
However, as stipulated in paragraph 18 of this Standard, regardless of the method chosen, the auditor must design and perform substantive tests for each group of significant transactions, account balances, and disclosures.
A5. The content of an audit procedure reflects the objective of that procedure (e.g., control testing or substantive testing) and the type of procedure (e.g., inspection, observation, interview, confirmation, recalculation, re-performance, or analytical procedure). The content of the audit procedure is the most important issue to determine after the risk assessment.
A6. The schedule of audit procedures is the time when audit procedures are performed, the phase or time at which audit evidence is applied.
A7. The scope of audit procedures refers to the number of audit procedures to be performed, for example, sample size or the number of observations of a control.
A8. The design and execution of subsequent audit procedures, the content, timing, and scope of which are determined based on an assessment of the risk of material misstatement at the assertion level, provide a clear link between the subsequent audit procedures and the auditor's risk assessment.
Risk-based audit procedures at the assertion level (guidance in paragraph 07(a) of this Standard)
Content
A9. The risks assessed by the auditor can influence both the type of audit procedures to be performed and the combination of those procedures. For example, when the auditor assesses a high risk, in addition to examining the documentation, the auditor may confirm with a third party the completeness of the contract terms. Furthermore, certain audit procedures may be more appropriate for some assertions than for others. For example, relating to revenue, control tests may be the most appropriate measure to address the risk of misstatement regarding “completeness,” while substantive tests may be the most appropriate measure to address the risk of misstatement regarding “occurrence.”
A10. When determining the scope of audit procedures, the auditor should consider the reasoning behind the risk assessment. For example, if a risk is assessed as low solely due to the specific characteristics of the transaction group without considering the related controls, the auditor may determine that performing only substantive analytical procedures would provide sufficient appropriate audit evidence. Conversely, if the risk is assessed as low due to effective internal controls, and the auditor intends to design substantive tests based on the effectiveness of the controls, the auditor will perform the control tests as prescribed in paragraph 08(a) of this Standard. An example of this is a relatively homogeneous, uncomplicated transaction group that is frequently processed and controlled by the entity's information system.
Itinerary
A11. Auditors may perform control tests or substantive tests at the mid-term or end-term audit. The higher the risk of material misstatement, the more the auditor needs to perform substantive procedures closer to or at the end of the period rather than earlier, or perform audit procedures without prior notice of their nature and timing (e.g., performing audit procedures at selected locations without prior notice). This is particularly relevant when selecting audit procedures to address the risk of fraud. For example, when discovering the risk of intentional misstatement or manipulation of data, the auditor may conclude that audit procedures to extend audit conclusions from the mid-term to the end-term audit would not be effective.
A12. Performing audit procedures before the end of the accounting period can help auditors detect significant problems early and thus address those problems with the support of the audited entity's management or design effective audit methods to address them.
A13. Certain audit procedures can only be performed at or after the end of the period, for example:
(1) Compare the figures on the financial statements with the figures on the accounting books;
(2) Check the adjusted items during the preparation and presentation of financial statements;
(3) Audit procedures to address the risk that at the end of the period, the audited entity has signed opaque sales contracts or has transactions that are not settled.
A14. The auditor's decision on when to perform audit procedures is influenced by relevant factors, including:
(1) Controlled environment;
(2) The time when appropriate information is available (for example, data in electronic files may then be modified, or procedures to be observed may only occur at certain times);
(3) The nature of the risk (for example, if there is a risk of revenue being inflated to meet expected profit levels by creating fictitious sales contracts after the end of the accounting period, the auditor may examine existing contracts at the end of the accounting period);
(4) The period or time related to the audit evidence.
Limit
A15. The auditor determines the scope of audit procedures deemed necessary after considering materiality, assessed risks, and the level of assurance the auditor expects to achieve. When the auditor achieves its objective by performing a combination of audit procedures, the scope of each procedure is considered separately. In general, the auditor needs to broaden the scope of audit procedures if the risk of material misstatement increases. For example, to address the risk of material misstatement due to fraud, the auditor may need to increase the sample size or perform substantive analytical procedures at a more detailed level. However, broadening the scope of audit procedures is only effective if the procedures themselves are appropriate to the specific risk.
A16. The use of computer-assisted auditing techniques (CAATs) can allow for the examination of a wide range of electronic transactions and data within electronic accounts. This technique can be useful when auditors decide to adjust the scope of testing, for example, when addressing the risk of material misstatement due to fraud. These techniques can be used to select samples from key electronic files to classify into specific transactions or to perform overall testing instead of sample testing.
Notes on auditing public sector entities
A17. When auditing entities in the public sector, the regulations of the State Audit Office and any other special audit requirements may influence the auditor's decision regarding the content, timing, and scope of subsequent audit procedures.
Notes on auditing small entities
A18. For small entities, auditors may not be able to identify many control activities, or the entity may have very little documentation demonstrating the existence or operation of such control activities. In this case, performing further audit procedures, primarily substantive testing, may be more effective. However, in rare cases, auditors may not be able to obtain sufficient appropriate audit evidence without the existence of control activities or other components of control.
Assessing high risk levels (guidance in paragraph 07(b) of this Standard)
A19. When more persuasive audit evidence is needed due to a higher assessed level of risk, the auditor may increase the amount of evidence, or gather more appropriate or reliable evidence, by concentrating the collection of evidence from third parties or gathering corroborating evidence from a number of independent sources.
Control experiment
Design and conduct control tests (guidance in paragraph 08 of this Standard)
A20. Control tests shall be performed only on those controls which the auditor determines are appropriately designed to prevent or detect and correct a material misstatement in an assertion. If fundamentally different controls are performed at different times during the audited period, each such control shall be considered separately.
A21. Testing the effectiveness of controls is different from understanding and evaluating the design and implementation of those controls. However, auditors can still use the same types of audit procedures to perform the test. Therefore, auditors may decide that the effective way to test is to test the effectiveness of controls simultaneously with evaluating their design and determining that those controls have been implemented.
A22. Although some risk assessment procedures may not be designed to perform control testing, they may still provide audit evidence regarding the effectiveness of controls and, therefore, serve as control testing. Examples of auditor's risk assessment procedures might include:
(1) Interview on the use of the budget by the Board of Directors;
(2) Observe the Board of Directors comparing projected and actual monthly costs;
(3) Check the reports to detect discrepancies between actual figures and plans.
These audit procedures not only provide insights into the entity's planning and whether that planning has been implemented, but can also provide audit evidence on the effectiveness of the entity's planning process in preventing and detecting material misclassification of costs.
A23. An auditor may design a control test to be performed concurrently with a substantive examination of the same transaction. Although the objective of a control test differs from that of a substantive examination, both procedures can be performed simultaneously on the same transaction, known as “dual testing.” For example, an auditor may design and evaluate the results of an examination of an invoice to determine whether the invoice was approved, while also providing substantive audit evidence of the transaction. Dual testing is designed and evaluated by considering each of the above audit objectives separately.
A24. According to paragraph 30 of Vietnamese Auditing Standard 315, in certain circumstances, the auditor may find that it is not possible to effectively design substantive tests that themselves provide sufficient appropriate audit evidence at the assertion level. This situation may occur when an entity operates its business using information technology and does not record or document its operations but only does so through the information technology system. In this case, the auditor must perform the relevant control tests as required in paragraph 08(b) of this Standard.
Audit evidence and expected reliability (guidance in paragraph 09 of this Standard)
A25. Auditors can achieve a higher degree of assurance regarding the effectiveness of control activities when the audit methodology primarily uses control testing, especially when it is not possible to obtain sufficient appropriate audit evidence solely from substantive testing.
Content and scope of the control test
Other audit procedures combined with interview procedures (guidance in paragraph 10(a) of this Standard)
A26. Interviewing alone is insufficient to test the effectiveness of controls; therefore, auditors need to perform other audit procedures in conjunction with interviews. Interviewing combined with testing or re-testing can provide greater assurance than combining interviewing and observation, as observation is only relevant at the time the transaction occurs.
A27. The content of a particular control will influence the type of procedures required to gather audit evidence regarding the effectiveness of that control. For example, if effectiveness is demonstrated in written form, the auditor may decide to examine the entity's documentation to gather audit evidence of that effectiveness. However, for other controls, documentation of the operation may be unavailable or inappropriate. For example, there may be no documentation of the operation of certain elements of the control environment, such as delegation of authority or responsibilities, or no documentation of certain types of control activities, such as computer-controlled control activities. In this case, the auditor may gather evidence of effectiveness through interviews in conjunction with other audit procedures, such as observation or the use of computer-assisted audit techniques.
Scope of the control test
A28. Auditors may need to broaden the scope of testing for a control when more compelling audit evidence is required regarding the effectiveness of that control. In addition to confidence in the controls, auditors may consider the following issues when determining the scope of control testing:
(1) Frequency of unit control performance during the period;
(2) The period during which the auditor is confident in the effectiveness of the control activities;
(3) Expected rate of error of a control;
(4) The appropriateness and reliability of audit evidence to be gathered regarding the effectiveness of control activities at the assertion level;
(5) The extent of audit evidence to be obtained from other control tests related to that assertion.
Vietnamese Auditing Standard No. 530 provides more detailed regulations and guidance on the scope of testing.
A29. Due to the inherent consistency of information technology processes, auditors may not need to extend the scope of testing to an automated control. An automated control will be performed consistently if the program (including the tables, files, or fixed data used in the program) does not change. If the auditor determines that an automated control operates as expected (this determination may be made at the time the control is implemented or at another time), the auditor may consider performing tests to determine that the control continues to operate effectively. Such tests may include determining:
(1) Program changes will not be made without proper control over those changes;
(2) The official version of the program used to process transactions;
(3) Other relevant general controls are effectively implemented.
These tests may also include determining that program changes have not been implemented, such as when an entity uses application software packages without modifying or maintaining the software. For example, auditors may examine IT security management records to gather audit evidence showing that no unauthorized access occurred during the period.
Testing for indirect controls (guidance in paragraph 10(b) of this Standard)
A30. In some cases, auditors may need to gather audit evidence to demonstrate the effectiveness of indirect controls. For example, when an auditor decides to examine the effectiveness of a user's review of an exception report on sales exceeding the credit limit, the user's review and subsequent related activities are controls that the auditor identifies as directly relevant. Controls over the accuracy of information in reports (e.g., general control over information technology) are considered indirect controls.
A31. Due to the inherent consistency of information technology processes, audit evidence regarding the implementation of an automated control application, when considered in conjunction with audit evidence regarding the effectiveness of the entity's overall controls (especially controls for change), may also provide significant audit evidence regarding the effectiveness of those controls.
Controlled testing schedule
Expected confidence period (guidance in paragraph 11 of this Standard)
A32. Audit evidence relating only to a single point in time may still be sufficient for audit purposes, for example, when testing a control on the entity's inventory count at the end of the accounting period. Conversely, if the auditor intends to rely on a control for the entire period, the auditor needs to perform tests capable of providing audit evidence that the control was effectively implemented at relevant points in time during that period. Such tests may include testing the monitoring of the entity's controls.
Use audit evidence gathered during the interim period (guidance in paragraph 12(b) of this Standard).
A33. When determining the additional audit evidence that needs to be gathered regarding controls implemented during the interim to end-of-period period, the auditor should consider factors including:
(1) The severity of material misstatement risks has been assessed at the assertion level;
(2) Specific controls that were tested during the interim period, as well as significant changes to those controls since they were tested, including changes to information systems, processing procedures and personnel;
(3) The extent to which audit evidence has been gathered regarding the effectiveness of those control activities;
(4) The remaining time of the audit period;
(5) The extent of substantive testing that the auditor intends to reduce is based on the confidence level of the controls;
(6) Controlled environment.
A34. Auditors may obtain additional audit evidence by performing control tests for the remaining period or examining the audited entity's oversight of its controls.
Use audit evidence obtained from previous audits (guidance in paragraph 13 of this Standard).
A35. In certain circumstances, audit evidence gathered from prior audits may also provide evidence for the current audit if the auditor performs audit procedures to demonstrate that prior audit evidence remains relevant to the current audit. For example, if during a prior audit the auditor determined that an entity's automatic control operated as expected, then in the current audit the auditor may gather audit evidence to determine whether any changes to this automatic control could affect its effectiveness, through interviews with management and examination of records to identify which controls have been changed. Audit evidence regarding these changes may help the auditor decide whether to increase or decrease the audit evidence to be gathered during the current period to assess the effectiveness of the control.
The controls have changed since the previous audits (guidance in paragraph 14(a) of this Standard).
A36. Changes that may affect the relevance of audit evidence obtained from prior audits, rendering that evidence no longer reliable for the auditor in the current audit. For example, changes in the system that allow the entity to receive a new report from the system may not affect the relevance of audit evidence obtained from a prior audit, but changes that cause data to be aggregated or calculated in a different way will affect the relevance of that audit evidence.
The controls have not changed since the previous audits (guidance in paragraph 14(b) of this Standard).
A37. Auditors should use professional judgment to decide whether they can continue to rely on audit evidence gathered in previous audits with respect to the following controls:
(a) The controls have not changed since the last trial;
(b) The controls do not significantly reduce the risk.
Auditors also use professional judgment to determine the appropriate timeframe for re-examining controls; however, as required by paragraph 14(b) of this Standard, this should be done at least once every three consecutive years.
A38. In general, the higher the risk of material misstatement, or the greater the confidence in the control, the shorter the time between re-examinations (if any). Factors that may shorten the time between re-examinations of a control, or cause the auditor to decide not to rely on audit evidence obtained from previous audits, include:
(1) Weakly controlled environment;
(2) Weaknesses in the supervision of controls;
(3) Related controls have a significant element that is performed manually;
(4) Changes in personnel have a significant impact on the application of a control;
(5) The changing situation leads to the need for a change in control;
(6) Weaknesses in general controls of information technology.
A39. When an auditor intends to rely on audit evidence obtained from prior audits with respect to certain controls, examining some of those controls in each audit provides corroborating information about the continuing effectiveness of the control environment. This helps the auditor decide whether the audit evidence obtained from prior audits can be relied upon.
Assessing the effectiveness of control activities (guidance in paragraphs 16-17 of this Standard)
A40. A material misstatement discovered by the auditor is a clear indication of the existence of a material deficiency in internal control.
A41. The concept of control effectiveness still shows that deviations may occur in the way an entity implements its controls. These deviations may be due to factors such as changes in key personnel, significant seasonal fluctuations in transaction volume, and subjective errors. The rate of deviation detected, particularly when compared to the expected rate of deviation, may indicate that the control cannot be relied upon to reduce the underlying risk to the level assessed by the auditor.
Basic testing (Guidance in paragraph 18 of this Standard)
A42. As required by paragraph 18 of this Standard, auditors are required to design and perform substantive tests for each class of transactions, account balances, and material disclosures, regardless of how material the risk assessment may be. This requirement stems from the fact that: (a) the auditor's risk assessment is judgmental, and therefore the auditor may not detect all risks of material misstatement; and (b) there are potential limitations in internal controls, including management's control.
Basic test content and scope
A43. Depending on the circumstances, the auditor may determine that:
(1) Performing only substantive analytical procedures is sufficient to reduce audit risk to an acceptable low level. For example, when the auditor assesses risk based on audit evidence obtained from control testing;
(2) Only detailed inspection is appropriate;
(3) Combining basic analysis and detailed testing procedures is most appropriate for handling the assessed risk.
A44. Fundamental analysis procedures are often applied to large numbers of transactions that are predictable over time. Vietnamese Auditing Standard No. 520 specifies and provides guidance on the application of analysis procedures in auditing.
A45. Auditors need to consider the nature of the risk and the assertion when designing substantive testing. For example, when substantive testing relates to the assertion of “existence” or “occurrence,” the auditor may select data from items already present in the financial statements and gather appropriate audit evidence. On the other hand, when substantive testing relates to the assertion of “completeness,” the auditor may need to select data from items that should be present in the financial statements and verify whether those items have already been presented in the financial statements.
A46. Because assessing the risk of material misstatement requires consideration of internal controls, auditors will need to broaden the scope of substantive testing when the results of control testing are unsatisfactory. However, broadening the scope of an audit procedure is only appropriate when that procedure is related to a specific risk.
A47. When designing detailed tests, the scope of the test is often considered as a selection of sample size. However, auditors need to consider other related issues, such as whether there are more efficient methods for selecting test elements (see paragraph 10 of Vietnamese Auditing Standard 500).
Consider the need for external verification procedures (guidance in paragraph 19 of this Standard).
A48. External confirmation procedures are typically performed when gathering audit evidence regarding assertions relating to account balances and associated elements, but are not necessarily limited to these items. For example, auditors may request external confirmation regarding contract terms, or transactions between the entity and other parties. External confirmation procedures may also be performed to gather audit evidence regarding the absence of certain conditions. For example, auditors may request confirmation that there are no “sub-arrangements” relating to assertions regarding the timeliness of revenue. External confirmation procedures may also provide appropriate audit evidence to address the risk of material misstatement that has been assessed in cases such as:
(1) Bank account balance and other information related to the relationship with the bank;
(2) Balances of receivables and contract terms;
(3) Inventory held by a third party in bonded warehouse for processing or consignment;
(4) Land use right certificate held by lawyer or lender for safekeeping or to guarantee payment ability;
(5) Investments held by third parties for safekeeping, or purchased on the stock exchange but not yet received as of the Balance Sheet date;
(6) Loans, including payment terms and limiting terms;
(7) Accounts payable balances and contract terms.
A49. Although external confirmations may provide appropriate audit evidence for certain assertions, they may provide less appropriate audit evidence for others. For example, external confirmations may provide audit evidence of the existence of receivables but not evidence of their collectibility.
A50. The auditor may determine that external confirmation procedures performed for a particular purpose may also help to gather audit evidence on other matters. For example, requests for confirmation of bank account balances often include requests for information relating to other assertions in the financial statements. Consideration of these matters may influence the auditor's decision on whether to perform external confirmation procedures.
A51. Factors that may help auditors determine whether to perform external confirmation procedures such as substantive audit tests include:
(1) Understanding of the confirming party regarding the matter to be confirmed: feedback may be more reliable if it is given by a person of the confirming party who has the necessary understanding of the matter to be confirmed;
(2) The ability or willingness of the confirming party to respond, e.g., the confirming party:
– We may not accept responsibility for responding to a confirmation request;
– It's clear that providing feedback is too costly and time-consuming;
– There may be concerns about legal liability arising from responding;
– Transactions can be accounted for in other currencies; or
– It can operate in an environment where responding to confirmation requests is not a critical aspect of daily operations.
In that case, the confirming party may not respond, respond irresponsibly, or may attempt to limit the reliability of the response.
(3) Objectivity of the certifying party: if the certifying party is a related party of the entity, the response to the certification requests may have lower reliability.
Substantive testing relating to the closing process for preparing financial statements (guidance in paragraph 20(b) of this Standard)
A52. The content and scope of the auditor's examination of other entries and adjustments depend on the nature and complexity of the entity's financial reporting process and the associated risks of material misstatement.
Substantive testing for significant risks (guidance in paragraph 21 of this Standard)
A53. Paragraph 21 of this Standard requires auditors to perform substantive tests to address risks that the auditor has identified as substantial. Audit evidence in the form of external confirmations received directly by the auditor from appropriate confirming parties may help the auditor obtain the high-reliability audit evidence necessary to address the risk of substantial misstatement due to fraud or error. For example, if the auditor finds that management is under pressure to achieve expected profit levels, there may be a risk that management will inflate revenue by recording revenue that is inconsistent with the terms of the sales contract, or by issuing invoices before delivery. In this case, the auditor may design external confirmation procedures to confirm outstanding balances and to confirm details of the sales contract, including timing, delivery terms, and return rights. Additionally, to support the external verification process, auditors may interview non-financial personnel within the entity regarding changes to sales contracts and delivery terms.
Schedule for conducting basic testing (guidance in paragraphs 22-23 of this Standard)
A54. In most cases, audit evidence from substantive tests obtained from a prior audit provides little evidence for the current audit. However, there are exceptions; for example, a tax authority dispatch obtained during a prior audit relating to the handling of a personal income tax violation that has not been altered may still be relevant to the current audit. In this case, the use of audit evidence from the prior audit's substantive tests may still be relevant to the current audit if the evidence and the related issue have not been substantially altered, and the auditor has performed audit procedures to demonstrate that the audit evidence from the prior audit remains relevant to the current audit.
Use audit evidence gathered during the interim period (guidance in paragraph 22 of this Standard).
A55. In some cases, auditors may find it effective to perform substantive testing at the mid-term audit and compare and contrast information relating to ending balances with comparable information at the mid-term audit to:
(a) Detecting anomalies;
(b) Investigate any anomalies (if any);
(c) Perform basic analysis or detailed testing procedures for the mid-term to end-term period.
A56. Performing substantive testing at the interim audit stage without further procedures in the later stages increases the risk that the auditor will not detect potential misstatements at the end of the period. This risk increases with the length of the remaining period. When considering the necessity of performing substantive testing at the interim stage, the auditor should consider the following factors:
(1) Control environment and other related controls;
(2) The availability of information necessary for the auditor's audit procedures at a later stage;
(3) Objectives of the basic test;
(4) The risk of material misstatement has been assessed;
(5) The nature of the trading group or account balance and related supporting data;
(6) The auditor's ability to perform appropriate substantive tests or a combination of substantive and control tests to cover the entire remaining period, thereby mitigating the risk of misstatement occurring at the end of the period that has not been detected by the auditor.
A57. The following factors may influence an auditor's decision on whether to perform substantive analytical procedures for the interim to end-of-period period:
(1) Whether the ending balance of a group of transactions or a specific account can be reasonably predicted in terms of value, relative volatility and composition of the ending balance;
(2) Whether the procedures for analyzing and adjusting transaction groups or account balances at the mid-term time and performing the unit's accounting closing are appropriate;
(3) The information system relating to the preparation and presentation of financial statements provides sufficient information relating to the ending balances and transactions during the remaining period to enable auditors to investigate:
(a) Unusual transactions or entries occurring at or near the end of the period;
(b) Other causes of significant fluctuations, or fluctuations that were expected but did not occur;
(c) Changes in the composition of trading groups or account balances.
Mistakes discovered at the time of the interim audit (guidance in paragraph 23 of this Standard)
A58. If the auditor concludes that the content, timing, or intended scope of substantive tests for the remaining period needs to be adjusted due to the discovery of unforeseen misstatements at the mid-period, then at the end of the period the auditor should extend or repeat the procedures performed at the mid-period.
The completeness of the presentation and disclosure of financial statements. (Guidance in paragraph 24 of this Standard)
A59. When evaluating the overall presentation of financial statements, including related disclosures, auditors should assess whether each report reflects the appropriate classification and description of financial information and whether the form, arrangement, and content of the financial statements and accompanying disclosures reflect this. This may include the terminology used, the quantity of information, the details presented, the classification of items in the report, and the basis for presenting the information.
Assessing the adequacy and appropriateness of audit evidence. (Refer to paragraphs 25-27 of this Standard)
A60. The audit of financial statements is an accumulative and constantly evolving process. When performing audit procedures as planned, audit evidence gathered may cause the auditor to change the content, timing, or scope of other audit procedures. The information gathered by the auditor may differ significantly from the information used as the basis for risk assessment. For example:
(1) The extent of the errors discovered by the auditor during substantive testing may alter the auditor's professional judgment regarding risk assessment and may indicate a material deficiency in internal control;
(2) The auditor may find inconsistencies in the accounting records, conflicting or omitted evidence;
(3) Analytical procedures performed during the overall review phase of the audit may reveal a risk of material misstatement that was not previously discovered.
In this case, the auditor may need to reassess the planned audit procedures based on a review of the risks assessed for all or some groups of transactions, account balances, or disclosures in the financial statements and related assertions. Paragraph 31 of Vietnamese Auditing Standard 315 provides more detailed guidance on the auditor's risk review.
A61. Auditors should not assume that fraud or error is an isolated incident. Therefore, auditors should consider how the discovery of the error will affect the assessed risks of material misstatement to determine whether the assessment remains appropriate.
A62. The auditor's professional judgment regarding the adequacy and appropriateness of audit evidence is influenced by the following factors:
(1) The severity of potential misstatements in the underlying data and the likelihood of material effects, individually or in combination with other potential misstatements, on the financial statements;
(2) The effectiveness of the unit's management's measures and controls for these risks;
(3) Experience gained from previous audits related to similar potential misstatements;
(4) Results of performing audit procedures, including whether those audit procedures detected any instances of fraud or error;
(5) Source and reliability of available information;
(6) Persuasiveness of audit evidence;
(7) The auditor's understanding of the entity and its environment, including internal controls.
Audit documents and records (Guidance in paragraph 28 of this Standard)
A63. The form and scope of audit documentation and records are matters of the auditor's professional judgment and are influenced by the nature, size and complexity of the audited entity and its internal controls, the availability of information within the entity, and the audit methods and techniques used.
*****