Line Vertical Thin Streamline Icon: https://streamlinehq.com
Text information
+ Issuing authority: Ministry of Finance
+ Document type: Other documents
Date of issuance: June 06, 2012
Effective date: July 1, 2014
Status: Still valid
01) This auditing standard specifies and guides the responsibilities of auditors and audit firms (hereinafter referred to as “auditors”) in identifying and assessing the risk of material misstatement in financial statements through understanding the audited entity and its environment, including internal controls. 02) Auditors and audit firms must comply with the provisions and guidance of this Standard in the process of auditing financial statements. The audited entity (client) and the parties using the audit results must have the necessary understanding of the provisions and guidance of this Standard to coordinate work with the auditor and audit firm and to manage relationships related to the audited information.
Category

Auditing Standard No. 315 on the Identification and Assessment of Risks of Material Misstatement, issued together with Circular 214/2012/TT-BTC.

 

VIETNAMESE AUDITING STANDARDS SYSTEM

Auditing Standard 315: Identifying and Assessing Risks of Material Misstatement Through Understanding the Audited Entity and its Environment

(Issued together with Circular No. 214/2012/TT-BTC) (December 6, 2012, Ministry of Finance)

I/ General Regulations

Scope of application

1. This auditing standard specifies and guides the responsibilities of auditors. and auditing firms (hereinafter referred to as "auditors") This involves identifying and assessing the risk of material misstatement in financial reporting through an understanding of the audited entity and its environment, including internal controls.

2. Auditors and audit firms must comply with the provisions and guidance of this Standard in the process of auditing financial statements.

The audited entity (client) and the parties using the audit results must have the necessary understanding of the regulations and guidance of this Standard in order to coordinate work with the auditor and the audit firm, as well as to manage relationships related to the audited information.

Target

3. Objectives of the auditor and auditing firms This involves identifying and assessing the risk of material misstatement due to fraud or error at the financial reporting and assertion levels, through an understanding of the audited entity and its environment, including internal controls, thereby providing a basis for designing and implementing measures to address the assessed risk of material misstatement.

Terminology explained

4. In Vietnamese auditing standards, the following terms are understood as follows:

(a) Basis of evidence: Statements made by the management of the audited entity, either directly or otherwise, regarding items and information presented in the financial statements and used by the auditor to consider potential misstatements;

(b) Business risk: This is the risk arising from conditions, events, circumstances, or the performance or non-performance of actions that have a significant impact that could lead to adverse effects on the ability to achieve the unit's objectives and implement its business strategy, or the risk arising from the inappropriate setting of objectives and business strategy;

(c) Internal control: Is a process designed, implemented, and maintained by the Board of Directors, the Management Board, and other individuals within the entity to provide reasonable assurance of the entity's ability to achieve its objectives in ensuring the reliability of financial reporting, ensuring operational efficiency and performance, and compliance with relevant laws and regulations. The term "control" is understood to mean any aspect of one or more components of internal control;

(d) Risk assessment procedures: These are audit procedures performed to gather insights into the audited entity and its environment, including internal controls, in order to identify and assess the risk of material misstatement due to fraud or error at the financial reporting level or assertion level;

(e) Significant risk: A risk of material misstatement that has been identified and assessed and which, in the auditor's judgment, should be given special attention during the audit.

II/ Standard Content

Requirement

Risk assessment procedures and related activities

5. Auditors must perform risk assessment procedures to establish a basis for identifying and assessing the risk of material misstatement at the financial statement and assertion levels. However, performing risk assessment procedures alone does not provide sufficient appropriate audit evidence for the auditor to form an audit opinion (see guidance in paragraphs A1–A5 of this Standard).

6. The risk assessment procedure must include the following steps:

(a) Interview management and other individuals within the entity who, in the auditor's judgment, are likely to provide information to support the identification of the risk of material misstatement due to fraud or error (see guidance in paragraph A6 of this Standard);

(b) Perform the analytical procedure (see guidance in paragraphs A7–A10 of this Standard);

(c) Observation and investigation (see guidance in paragraph A11 of this Standard).

7. The auditor must consider whether information gathered from client acceptance or retention assessment procedures is relevant to determining the risk of material misstatement.

8. In cases where the member of the Board of Directors responsible for the overall audit has provided other services to the audited entity, that member of the Board of Directors responsible for the overall audit must consider whether the information previously gathered is appropriate to determine the risk of material misstatement.

9. Where it is intended to use information gathered from experience working with the audited entity and from audit procedures performed in prior years or experience from previous audits, the auditor must consider whether changes have occurred between the previous audit and the current audit that may affect the relevance of such information to the current audit (see guidance in paragraphs A12–A13 of this Standard).

10. The Board of Directors responsible for the overall audit and the principal members of the audit team shall discuss the likelihood of material misstatement in the entity's financial statements and whether the financial reporting framework is appropriate to the entity's conditions and circumstances. The Board of Directors responsible for the overall audit shall decide on matters to be communicated to audit team members not participating in the discussion (see guidance in paragraphs A14–A16 of this Standard).

The necessary understanding includes knowledge of the audited entity and its environment, including internal controls.

The audited entity and its environment

11. Auditors must find out the following information:

(a) The industry, legal regulations and other external factors, including the applicable financial reporting framework (see guidance in paragraphs A17–A22 of this Standard);

(b) Characteristics of the unit, including:

(i) Field of activity;

(ii) Type of ownership and management structure;

(iii) The forms of investment in which the entity is currently and will be involved, including investments in special purpose entities;

(iv) Organizational structure, production and business management, and capital structure of the unit.

This information helps auditors understand the groups of transactions, account balances, and disclosures that need to be presented in the entity's financial statements (see guidance in paragraphs A23–A27 of this Standard).

(c) The accounting policies chosen by the entity and the reasons for any changes (if any). The auditor must assess whether the accounting policies applied by the entity are appropriate to the entity's business activities, consistent with the financial reporting framework and accounting policies applied by entities in the same business sector (see guidance in paragraph A28 of this Standard).

(d) The entity's objectives, strategies, and related business risks that could lead to a risk of material misstatement (see guidance in paragraphs A29–A35 of this Standard);

(e) Measurement and evaluation of the unit's performance (see guidance in paragraphs A36–A41 of this Standard).

Internal controls of the audited entity

12. The auditor must ascertain information regarding the entity's internal controls relevant to the audit. While most controls relevant to an audit relate to the financial statements, not all controls related to the financial statements are relevant to the audit. The auditor must use professional judgment to determine which controls, individually or in combination with others, are relevant to the audit (see guidance in paragraphs A42–A65 of this Standard).

Content and level of understanding of relevant controls

13. When gathering information about controls relevant to the audit, the auditor must assess the design of the controls and determine whether these controls have been implemented at the entity by conducting additional audit procedures beyond interviewing the entity's personnel (see guidance in paragraphs A66–A68 of this Standard).

Components of internal control

Controlled environment

14. Auditors must understand the entity's control environment. In the process of understanding, auditors must assess whether:

(a) Has the Board of Directors, under the supervision of the Board of Trustees, designed and maintained a culture of integrity and ethical conduct?

(b) Do the strengths of the control environment combine to form a solid foundation for other components of internal control, and are those components weakened by deficiencies in the control environment (see guidance in paragraphs A69–A78 of this Standard)?

The organization's risk assessment process

15. The auditor must determine whether the entity has a process in place to:

(a) Identify business risks related to the objectives of preparing and presenting financial statements;

(b) Estimate the level of risk;

(c) Assess the likelihood of risk occurring;

(d) Determine appropriate actions to be taken with respect to those risks (see guidance in paragraph A79 of this Standard).

16. If the entity has a risk assessment procedure as described in paragraph 15 of this Standard (hereinafter referred to as the entity’s risk assessment procedure), the auditor shall investigate the content and results of that procedure. If the auditor discovers a risk of material misstatement that was not detected by the entity’s management, the auditor shall assess whether this risk is related to a risk that the entity’s risk assessment procedure was supposed to have detected but was not actually detected. If such a risk exists, the auditor shall investigate why the entity’s risk assessment procedure failed to detect it and assess whether the procedure was appropriate for the entity’s conditions, or determine whether there are material deficiencies in internal controls related to the entity’s risk assessment procedure.

17. If the entity does not have a procedure or has a procedure that is not standardized, the auditor must discuss with the entity's management whether business risks related to the objectives of preparing and presenting financial statements have been identified and how they have been addressed. The auditor must assess whether the absence of a documented risk assessment procedure is appropriate in the specific circumstances or whether the absence of a documented procedure indicates a material deficiency in the entity's internal controls (see guidance in paragraph A80 of this Standard).

Information systems relate to the preparation and presentation of financial reports, including related business processes and information exchange.

18. Auditors must understand the information systems related to the preparation and presentation of financial statements, including relevant business processes, comprising the following:

(a) Transaction groups in the entity's operations that are significant to the financial statements;

(b) Procedures performed in information technology systems or manually, to create, record, process, and modify transactions, record them in the General Ledger, and present financial statements;

(c) The relevant accounting documents, supporting information and specific items on the financial statements used to create, record, process and report the transaction, including the correction of inaccurate information and the way in which the data is reflected in the General Ledger. These accounting documents may be in paper or electronic form;

(d) How the information system receives events and circumstances that are significant to financial reporting (excluding transactions);

(e) The entity's process for preparing and presenting financial statements, including accounting estimates and significant disclosures;

(f) Controls for journal entries, including unusual journal entries, to recognize infrequent transactions, unusual transactions, or adjustments (see guidance in paragraphs A81–A85 of this Standard).

19. The auditor must understand how the entity communicates information regarding roles, responsibilities, and other significant matters related to the financial statements, including (see guidance in paragraphs A86–A87 of this Standard):

(a) Exchange between the Board of Directors and the Management Board;

(b) Information with external parties, for example with competent regulatory authorities.

Control activities related to the audit

20. The auditor must understand the control activities related to the audit that, in the auditor's judgment, are necessary to assess the risk of material misstatement at the assertion level and to design subsequent audit procedures for the assessed risk. For each audit, the auditor is not required to understand all control activities related to each group of transactions, account balances, disclosures in the financial statements, or to each relevant assertion (see guidance in paragraphs A88–A94 of this Standard).

21. When examining an entity's control activities, the auditor must understand how the entity handles risks arising from information technology (see guidance in paragraphs A95–A97 of this Standard).

Monitoring controls

22. The auditor must understand the primary methods the entity uses to monitor its internal controls in the preparation and presentation of financial statements, including the controls relevant to the audit and how the entity has corrected deficiencies in its controls (see guidance in paragraphs A98–A100 of this Standard).

23. If the entity has an internal audit (see the term “internal audit” in paragraph 07(a) of Vietnamese Auditing Standard 610), the auditor must investigate the following to determine whether the internal audit is relevant to the audit:

(a) The responsibilities and role of internal audit within the unit's organizational structure;

(b) Activities that the internal audit has performed and will perform (see guidance in paragraphs A101–A103 of this Standard).

24. Auditors must ascertain the source of information used in the monitoring activities of the entity and facility so that Management can assess that the information is sufficiently reliable for monitoring purposes (see guidance in paragraph A104 of this Standard).

Identify and assess the risk of material misstatement.

25. To provide a basis for designing and implementing subsequent audit procedures, the auditor must identify and assess the risk of material misstatement at the following levels:

(a) Level of financial reporting (see guidance in paragraphs A105–A108 of this Standard);

(b) The level of underlying data for groups of transactions, account balances, and disclosures (see guidance in paragraphs A109–A113 of this Standard).

26. To meet the requirements of paragraph 25 of this Standard, the auditor must:

(a) Identifying risks through an understanding of the entity and its environment, including an understanding of appropriate controls related to risks and identifying risks through a review of transaction groups, account balances and disclosures in the financial statements (see guidance in paragraphs A114–A115 of this Standard);

(b) Assess the identified risks and evaluate whether they have a pervasive impact on the overall financial statements and a potential impact on multiple assertions;

(c) Relate the identified risks to potential misstatements at the assertion level and consider which controls the auditor intends to test (see guidance in paragraphs A116–A118 of this Standard);

(d) Consider the possibility of error, including the possibility of multiple errors, and whether such a potential error could lead to a material error.

Risks that require special attention during auditing.

27. When performing the risk assessment procedure set out in paragraph 25 of this Standard, the auditor shall rely on professional judgment to determine whether the identified risk is substantial. In making this judgment, the auditor shall exclude the influence of identified controls on that risk.

28. When determining which risks are considered significant, auditors must consider at least the following:

(a) Is that risk a risk arising from fraud?

(b) Is that risk related to recent major changes in the economy, in accounting and other fields, and therefore requires special attention?

(c) The complexity of the transactions;

(d) Is that risk associated with significant transactions with related parties?

(e) The degree of subjectivity in quantifying financial information related to risk, especially information whose quantification is uncertain;

(f) Does that risk relate to large transactions outside the entity's normal course of business, or to transactions that appear unusual (see guidance in paragraphs A119–A123 of this Standard)?

29. When a significant risk has been identified, the auditor must investigate the entity's controls, including control activities, that are relevant to that risk (see guidance in paragraphs A124–A126 of this Standard).

These are risks that, if only basic tests were performed, would not provide sufficient appropriate audit evidence.

30. For certain types of risks, the auditor may judge that performing only substantive tests will not yield sufficient appropriate audit evidence. These risks relate to inaccurate or incomplete recording of recurring and significant groups of transactions and account balances that are typically processed automatically with little or no manual intervention. In this case, the entity’s controls for these risks are considered relevant to the audit, and the auditor must investigate those controls (see guidance in paragraphs A127–A129 of this Standard).

Review the risk assessment.

31. The auditor's assessment of the risk of material misstatement at the assertion level may change during the audit as the auditor obtains additional audit evidence. If the audit evidence obtained from performing subsequent audit procedures or newly obtained information is inconsistent with the initial audit evidence on which the auditor relied to assess the risk, the auditor must reconsider those previous assessments and thereby modify the subsequent audit procedures performed (see guidance in paragraph A130 of this Standard).

Audit documents and records

32. The auditor must retain in the audit file (see paragraphs 08-11 and A6 of Vietnamese Auditing Standard No. 230):

(a) The communications between the audit team members as prescribed in paragraph 10 of this Standard, and all significant decisions agreed upon;

(b) The key insights gained about the audited entity and its environment as prescribed in paragraph 11 of this Standard and each component of internal control as prescribed in paragraphs 14–24 of this Standard, the sources of information the auditor used to gather these insights and the risk assessment procedures performed;

(c) Risks of material misstatement have been identified and assessed at the financial reporting and assertion levels as required by paragraph 25 of this Standard;

(d) The identified risks and related controls that the auditor has explored, as required by paragraphs 27–30 of this Standard (see guidance in paragraphs A131–A134 of this Standard).

III/ Application Instructions

When implementing this Standard, reference should be made to Vietnamese Auditing Standard No. 200.

Risk assessment procedures and related activities (Guidance in paragraph 05 of this Standard)

A1. Gathering insights into the audited entity and its environment, including internal controls (hereinafter referred to as “entity insights”) is a continuous and dynamic process of collecting, updating, and analyzing information throughout the audit process. Entity insights provide the auditor with a basis for audit planning and making professional judgments throughout the audit process, for example in tasks such as:

(1) Assess the risk of material misstatement in the financial statements;

(2) Determining materiality level according to the provisions of Vietnamese Auditing Standard No. 320;

(3) Assessing the appropriateness of the selection and application of accounting policies and the completeness and suitability of financial statement disclosures;

(4) Identify items that require special attention during the audit, for example, transactions with related parties, the appropriateness of the management's going concern assumption, or consideration of the economic purpose of the transactions;

(5) Make estimates to use when performing the analytical procedure;

(6) Measures to address the assessed risk of material misstatement, including designing and implementing further audit procedures to obtain sufficient appropriate audit evidence;

(7) Assess the adequacy and appropriateness of the audit evidence gathered, such as assessing the appropriateness of assumptions and of the oral and written statements of the Board of Directors.

A2. Auditors may use information obtained from risk assessment procedures and related activities as audit evidence to support the assessment of the risk of material misstatement. In addition, auditors may still obtain audit evidence regarding groups of transactions, account balances or disclosures and related assertions, and regarding the effectiveness of control activities, even if these procedures are not specifically planned as substantive or control testing. Auditors may also choose to conduct substantive or control testing concurrently with risk assessment procedures because this is an efficient approach.

A3. Auditors should use professional judgment to determine the level of understanding required. The main consideration for auditors is whether existing knowledge meets the objectives set out in this Standard. This Standard does not require auditors to have the same in-depth, comprehensive understanding of the entity as is required of management in the operation of the entity.

A4. This standard specifies and guides the assessment of risks, including risks of fraud and risks of error. However, due to the severity of fraud, paragraphs 12–14 of Vietnamese Auditing Standard 240 provide detailed procedures for assessing risks and related activities to gather information to identify risks of material misstatement due to fraud.

A5. In the process of gathering the necessary understanding of the audited entity (see paragraphs 11–24 of this Standard), the auditor must perform all risk assessment procedures as prescribed in paragraph 06 of this Standard, but not necessarily all procedures for every aspect of the information to be understood. The auditor may apply other procedures if it deems that the information gathered would be useful in determining the risk of material misstatement. Examples of other procedures include:

(1) Review information obtained from external sources such as trade and economic journals, expert analysis reports, banks or rating organizations; or industry regulatory journals and financial journals;

(2) Interviews with legal consultants and external valuation experts that the audited entity has previously used.

Interviewing the Board of Directors and other individuals within the audited entity. (Guidance in paragraph 06(a) of this Standard)

A6. Auditors obtain most of their information from interviews with the Board of Directors and those responsible for preparing and presenting the financial statements. However, auditors may also interview other individuals and employees at various levels and positions within the audited entity to gather useful information or other perspectives that may help identify the risk of material misstatement. For example:

(1) Direct interviews with the Board of Directors can help auditors understand the financial reporting environment;

(2) Direct interviews with internal auditors can help provide information on the procedures the internal auditors have taken during the year, relating to the design and effectiveness of internal controls and whether the Board of Directors has taken appropriate measures in response to the internal auditors' findings;

(3) Interviewing staff responsible for recording, processing and accounting for complex and unusual transactions can help auditors assess the appropriateness of the entity's choice and application of accounting policies;

(4) Direct interviews with the entity's lawyer can provide information on issues such as litigation, compliance with laws and regulations, information on fraud and allegations of fraud affecting the entity, warranty obligations, after-sales service, agreements (e.g., joint ventures, partnerships) with business partners and the meaning of contract terms;

(5) Direct interviews with marketing and sales staff can provide information on changes in market strategy, unit sales trends, or customer agreements.

Analytical procedures (Guidance in paragraph 06(b) of this Standard)

A7. The Analytical procedures used in risk assessment can help auditors identify characteristics of the entity that the auditor was previously unaware of and help assess the risk of material misstatement as a basis for designing and implementing audit procedures for the assessed risk. Analytical procedures used in the risk assessment process may involve financial and non-financial information, such as the relationship between revenue and sales volume.

A8. Analytical procedures can help auditors identify the existence of unusual transactions, events, figures, proportions, and trends that may be indicative of problems affecting the audit. Detecting unusual and unexpected relationships can help auditors identify risks of material misstatement, particularly risks of material misstatement due to fraud.

A9. However, when analytical procedures use aggregated data (such as when performing analytical procedures to assess risk), the results of the analysis only provide initial general information about the likelihood of material misstatement. Therefore, considering other information gathered when determining the risk of material misstatement along with the results of the analytical procedures can help the auditor understand and evaluate the results of the analytical procedures.

Notes on auditing small entities

A10. Some small entities may not have interim or monthly financial information available for analysis. In this case, although auditors may perform certain analytical procedures to support audit planning or gather information through interviews, they may need to plan to perform analytical procedures to identify and assess the risk of material misstatement as soon as the draft financial statements of the audited entity are available.

Observation and investigation (Guidance in paragraph 06(c) of this Standard)

A11. Observations and investigations can support interviews with management and other individuals within the entity, and provide additional information about the audited entity and its environment. Examples of observations and investigations include:

(1) Unit activities;

(2) Documents (such as business plans and strategies), records, and guidance documents on internal control;

(3) Types of reports prepared by the Board of Directors (such as quarterly management reports and interim financial reports) and reports prepared by the Board of Management (such as minutes of board meetings);

(4) Infrastructure, factories, machinery and equipment…

Information gathered from previous audits. (Guidance in paragraph 09 of this Standard)

A12. Prior experience with the audited entity and the audit procedures performed in previous audits may provide the auditor with information such as:

(1) Past errors and whether corrections have been made in a timely manner;

(2) Characteristics of the audited entity and its environment, including internal controls (including deficiencies in internal controls);

(3) Significant changes in the entity or in the entity's operations from the previous accounting period to the present time may give the auditor a more complete understanding of the entity to identify and assess the risk of material misstatement.

A13. Auditors must assess whether information obtained from a previous audit remains relevant for use in the current audit, as changes in the control environment may affect the relevance of previously obtained information. To determine whether these changes affect the relevance of the information, auditors may need to conduct interviews and perform other appropriate audit procedures, such as performing walk-throughs of relevant processes.

Discussion within the audit team. (Guidance in paragraph 10 of this Standard)

A14. Discussions within the audit team regarding the potential for material misstatement in the financial statements aim to:

(1) Create opportunities for experienced members of the audit team, including members of the Board of Directors in charge of the overall audit, to share their perspectives based on their experience and understanding of the entity;

(2) Allows audit team members to exchange information about potential business risks the entity may face, items in the financial statements susceptible to material misstatement due to fraud or error, and how such misstatement may occur;

(3) To help audit team members better understand potential material misstatements in specific financial statements for each item assigned to them, as well as understand how the results of the audit procedures they are performing affect the audit, including determining the content, timing and scope of subsequent audit procedures;

(4) To provide a basis for audit team members to exchange and share newly gathered information during the audit that affects the assessment of risks of material misstatement or the audit procedures performed for these risks.

Paragraph 15 of Vietnamese Auditing Standard 240 specifies the content of discussions among audit team members regarding fraud risk.

A15. An audit team discussion (especially for multi-location audits) may not require the participation of all audit team members, nor does it necessarily require the full content of the discussion to be communicated to each member. The Board of Directors responsible for the overall audit may discuss only with the key members of the audit team, including experts and those responsible for the audit of subsidiaries and affiliated entities, if necessary. The Board of Directors responsible for the overall audit may delegate communication with other members, taking into account the information that needs to be communicated to the entire audit team. Communication should be planned with the approval of the Board of Directors responsible for the overall audit.

Notes on auditing small entities

A16. Many small audits may be performed by a single person (an auditor or a member of the Board of Directors). In this case, that member is both responsible for designing the audit plan and for identifying material misstatements due to fraud or error in the financial statements; however, this must still be subject to review by another auditor or member of the Board of Directors.

The necessary understanding includes knowledge of the audited entity and its environment, including internal controls.

The audited entity and its environment

Industry, legal, and other external factors. (Guidance in paragraph 11(a) of this Standard)

Industry factors

A17. Factors influencing the industry include the competitive environment, relationships with suppliers and customers, and scientific and technological advancements. Auditors need to pay attention to issues such as:

(1) Markets and competition, including demand, production capacity and price competition;

(2) Activities that are cyclical or seasonal;

(3) Technology related to the unit's products;

(4) Energy supply and costs.

A18. The industry in which the entity operates may give rise to risks of material misstatement due to the nature of its business operations or applicable regulations. For example, long-term contracts may involve large estimates of revenue and expenses, thus increasing the risk of material misstatement. In this case, as required by paragraph 14 of Vietnamese Auditing Standard 220, the audit team must have members with sufficient expertise and relevant experience.

Legal factors

A19. Legal factors include the legal environment, including the applicable framework for the preparation and presentation of financial reports, and the political and legal environment. Examples of issues auditors need to consider include:

(1) The accounting system that the industry is applying and industry practices (if any);

(2) System of regulations for each profession;

(3) The legal system and regulations have a significant impact on the unit's operations, including direct supervisory activities;

(4) Taxes (corporate income tax and other taxes);

(5) Policies issued by the State that are currently affecting the unit's operations, for example, monetary policy, foreign exchange controls, fiscal policy, financial incentives (e.g., government aid programs), tariff barriers or trade restriction policies;

(6) Environmental regulations affecting the unit's profession and operations.

A20. Paragraph 12 of Vietnamese Auditing Standard No. 250 specifies the legal system and regulations applicable to the entity and its industry.

Notes on auditing public sector entities

A21. For entities in the public sector, their operations may be affected by laws, regulations, or guidelines from regulatory bodies. Auditors need to consider these issues during the process of gathering information about the entity and its environment.

Other external factors

A22. Auditors may need to investigate other external factors affecting the entity such as the general economic situation, interest rates and available financial resources, inflation, or exchange rate fluctuations.

Characteristics of the unit (Guidance in paragraph 11(b) of this Standard)

A23. Understanding the characteristics of the entity helps auditors understand issues such as:

(1) Whether the entity has a complex organizational structure, such as having subsidiaries or affiliates in multiple locations. Complex organizational structures often lead to problems that can increase the risk of material misstatements. Such problems may include whether the value of goodwill, joint ventures, investments or special-purpose entities is properly accounted for;

(2) Ownership and relationships between owners and other individuals or entities. Understanding this helps auditors determine whether transactions with related parties have been properly recorded and accounted for. Vietnamese Auditing Standard No. 550 stipulates and guides auditors to consider issues related to related parties.

A24. Examples of some issues that auditors may need to consider when learning about the characteristics of an entity include:

(1) Issues related to business operations such as:

– The nature of revenue sources, products or services, and markets, including e-commerce such as selling and marketing via the Internet;

– Carrying out activities (e.g., production stages and processes, activities subject to environmental risks);

– Joint ventures, partnerships, and outsourcing activities;

– Geographic dispersion and market segmentation;

– Production location, warehouse, office, quantity and location of inventory;

– Key customers and suppliers of goods and services, labor agreements (including union membership, retirement and other post-employment benefits, stock options or other incentives, and government regulations relating to employees);

– Activities and expenditures for research and development;

– Transactions with related parties.

(2) Issues related to investments and investment activities such as:

– The purchase, sale, or split of a business has been planned or recently completed;

– Buying and selling securities and debt;

– Capital investment activities;

– Investments in non-consolidated entities, including partnerships, joint ventures, and special-purpose entities.

(3) Issues related to grants and funding activities such as:

– Major subsidiaries and affiliated companies, including those that are consolidated or not consolidated;

– The debt structure and related terms, including financing and leasing agreements, are reflected off the Balance Sheet;

– Beneficiaries (domestic, foreign, business reputation and experience) and related parties;

– Utilize derivative financial instruments.

(4) Issues related to the preparation and presentation of financial statements such as:

– Accounting principles and specific practices of each industry, including those with unique characteristics (for example, principles applied to bank loans and investments, or research and development in the pharmaceutical industry);

– Methods of revenue recognition;

– Fair value accounting;

– Assets, liabilities, and transactions denominated in foreign currencies;

– Accounting for unusual or complex transactions, including disputed transactions or new areas (for example, accounting for stock-based bonuses).

A25. Significant changes to the entity compared to prior periods may give rise to or alter the risk of material misstatement.

Characteristics of special-purpose units

A26. A special purpose entity is an entity established for a narrow and predetermined purpose, such as leasing assets or securitizing financial assets, or to conduct research and development activities. This entity may be a business, trust, partnership, or subsidiary without legal personality. The entity creating the special purpose entity typically transfers assets to the special purpose entity (as part of a financial asset write-off), creates a right to use the special purpose entity's assets, or provides services to the special purpose entity, while other parties may provide funding to the special purpose entity. As guided in paragraph A7 of Vietnamese Auditing Standard 550, in some cases, a special purpose entity may be a related party of the audited entity.

A27. Financial reporting frameworks typically specify the particular conditions under which a special purpose entity must be consolidated in its financial reporting. Interpreting the provisions of a financial reporting framework often requires detailed knowledge of the agreements relating to the special purpose entity.

The accounting policies that the entity chooses to apply. (Guidance in paragraph 11(c) of this Standard)

A28. Understanding the accounting policies that the entity chooses to apply may include the following issues:

(1) The methods the unit uses to account for significant and unusual transactions;

(2) The impact of key accounting policies on controversial issues and new areas due to lack of specific or consistent guidance;

(3) Changes in the unit's accounting policy;

(4) Standards for preparing and presenting financial reports, new laws and regulations applicable to the entity, and the timing and manner in which the entity implements these requirements.

Business objectives, strategies, and associated risks. (Guidance in paragraph 11(d) of this Standard)

A29. The entity operates within the context of its industry, regulatory requirements, and other internal and external factors. To adapt to these factors, the entity's Board of Directors or management must set objectives to develop an overall plan for the entity. The strategy consists of the methods used by the Board of Directors to achieve these objectives. The entity's objectives and strategy may change over time.

A30. Business risk is generally broader and includes the risk of material misstatement in financial reporting. Business risk can arise from changes within the entity or from complex operations within the entity. Failure to recognize the need for change can also give rise to business risk. Business risk can arise from issues such as:

(1) The strategy for developing new products or services was unsuccessful;

(2) The market is not large enough to consume goods and services (even if that market has been successfully developed);

(3) Defective products or services may result in legal liability or damage the reputation of the entity.

A31. Understanding the business risks faced by an entity will increase the likelihood of detecting risks of material misstatement, as most business risks will have financial consequences, thus affecting the entity's financial statements. However, auditors are not responsible for detecting or assessing all types of business risks because not all business risks give rise to risks of material misstatement.

A32. When examining the objectives, strategies, and related business risks that may lead to the risk of material misstatement in the entity's financial statements, auditors may need to consider issues such as:

(1) Industry development (which may lead to related business risks such as: the unit does not have enough human resources and professional capacity to adapt to changes in the industry in which it operates);

(2) New products or services (which may lead to related business risks such as increased liability for the product);

(3) Expanding the scope of business (which may lead to related business risks such as inaccurate market demand estimates);

(4) New accounting requirements (which may lead to related business risks such as: incomplete or incorrect implementation of new accounting requirements or increased implementation costs);

(5) Legal regulations (which may lead to related business risks such as: increased legal compliance responsibility);

(6) The unit's current and future financial requirements (which may lead to related business risks such as: loss of funding due to the unit's inability to meet the requirements);

(7) Use of information technology (which may lead to related business risks such as: systems and procedures that are incompatible with each other);

(8) The impact of implementing a strategy, especially the impact that leads to new accounting requirements (which may lead to related business risks such as: incomplete or inappropriate implementation).

A33. A business risk may result in a risk of material misstatement with respect to groups of transactions, account balances, and disclosures at the assertion or financial reporting level. For example, a business risk arising from a shrinking customer base may increase the risk of material misstatement in the valuation of receivables. However, this risk can also have long-term consequences, especially in a recessionary economy, and auditors must consider this when assessing the appropriateness of the going concern assumption. Therefore, to determine whether a business risk may result in a risk of material misstatement, auditors need to consider the specific circumstances of the entity. Appendix 02 of this Standard provides examples of situations and events that may result in a risk of material misstatement.

A34. Typically, the Board of Directors identifies business risks and develops strategies to mitigate them. This risk assessment process is part of internal control, as defined in paragraph 15 and guided by paragraphs A79–A80 of this Standard.

Notes on auditing public sector entities

A35. When auditing entities in the public sector, issues related to public accountability can significantly impact the objectives of the Board of Directors, and these objectives may include those mandated by law and government regulatory bodies.

Measuring and evaluating the unit's performance (Guidance in paragraph 11(e) of this Standard)

A36. Management and other individuals will measure and evaluate issues identified as material. Measuring performance, whether from within or outside the entity, will create pressures on the entity. These pressures, in turn, will motivate management to take actions to improve performance or distort financial reporting. Therefore, understanding how the entity's performance is measured will help auditors consider whether pressures to achieve performance goals may lead to actions by management that increase the risk of material misstatement, including misstatement due to fraud. Vietnamese Auditing Standard 240 specifies and provides guidance on the risks of fraud.

A37. The measurement and evaluation of performance may have the same purpose, but are not entirely the same as the monitoring of controls (a component of internal control, as described in paragraphs A98–A104 of this Standard):

(1) The measurement and evaluation of performance focuses on whether the business achieves the goals set by the Board of Directors (or a third party);

(2) Monitoring controls is closely related to the effectiveness of internal control.

However, in some situations, evaluation criteria also provide information that helps the Board of Directors identify deficiencies in internal control.

A38. Examples of internal information used by management to measure and evaluate performance that auditors may consider include:

(1) Key performance indicators (financial and non-financial), key ratios, trends and performance statistics;

(2) Analyze the results of operations in each stage;

(3) Financial plans, forecasts, analysis of fluctuations, information on departments and reports evaluating the performance of departments, divisions or other levels;

(4) Employee performance evaluation and preferential salary policy;

(5) Compare the unit's performance with competitors.

A39. External organizations and individuals can also measure and evaluate the performance of an entity. For example, external information such as analytical reports and credit rating reports can provide auditors with useful information. These types of reports are usually collected from the audited entity.

A40. Internal measurement and evaluation may reveal unexpected results or trends requiring management to identify the causes and take corrective measures (in some situations, timely detection and correction of errors). Performance measurement and evaluation may also indicate to auditors the real risk of misstatement related to financial reporting. For example, performance measurement and evaluation may reveal unusually rapid growth or profitability compared to other units in the industry. In particular, this information, when combined with other factors such as performance-based bonuses or compensation schemes, may reveal a potential risk of bias on the part of management in preparing financial statements.

Notes on auditing small entities

A41. Smaller entities often lack performance measurement and evaluation processes. Interviews with management will provide auditors with information on key performance indicators and how to take appropriate measures. If the interview reveals that the entity does not perform performance measurement and evaluation, there may be an increased risk of undetected and uncorrected errors.

Internal controls of the audited entity (Guidance in paragraph 12 of this Standard)

A42. Understanding internal controls helps auditors identify potential misstatements and factors influencing the risk of material misstatement, and determine the nature, timing, and scope of subsequent audit procedures.

A43. Important guidance on internal control is presented in the following four sections:

(1) The nature and general characteristics of internal control;

(2) Controls related to the audit;

(3) Content and level of understanding of related controls;

(4) Components of internal control.

The nature and general characteristics of internal control.

The purpose of internal control

A44. Internal controls are designed, implemented, and maintained to address identified business risks that pose a risk of the entity failing to achieve one or more of the objectives related to:

(1) Reliability of the process of preparing and presenting financial reports;

(2) Effectiveness and operational efficiency;

(3) Compliance with applicable laws and regulations.

The design, implementation, and maintenance of internal controls can vary depending on the size and complexity of the organization.

Notes on auditing small entities

A45. Smaller units may use fewer functions, fewer procedures, and simpler processes and procedures to achieve their goals.

Limitations of internal control

A46. Internal control, however effective, can only provide an entity with reasonable assurance that it will achieve its financial reporting objectives. The ability to achieve these objectives is affected by the inherent limitations of internal control. These limitations include the possibility of human error in decision-making and the potential for failure of internal control due to human error, for example, errors in the design or modification of a control. Similarly, a control may be ineffective if information collected for internal control purposes is not used appropriately because the person responsible for reviewing this information does not fully understand its purpose or does not take appropriate action.

A47. In addition, controls may be compromised by collusion between two or more individuals or by control exerted by the Board of Directors. For example, the Board of Directors may have “sub-agreements” with customers to alter the terms of the unit’s standard sales contract, leading to inaccurate revenue recognition. Similarly, the function of computer software to detect and report transactions exceeding credit limits may be compromised or neutralized.

A48. In addition, when designing and implementing controls, the Board of Directors may make judgments about the scope and extent of the controls it chooses to implement and about the scope and extent of the risks it decides to accept.

Notes on auditing small entities

A49. Small units typically have fewer personnel, thus limiting the distribution of responsibilities and authority. However, in a small unit where the owner is also the director, that person has better supervisory capabilities than in a large unit. This supervision can compensate for the limitations in the distribution of responsibilities and authority.

A50. On the other hand, the owner who is also the Director is more likely to exert control due to the simpler structure of the internal control system. Auditors need to consider this when identifying risks of material misstatement due to fraud.

The division of internal control into components

A51. In Vietnamese auditing standards, internal control is divided into five components to provide a framework for auditors to consider how different aspects of an entity's internal control may affect the audit:

(a) Controlled environment;

(b) The unit's risk assessment process;

(c) Information systems related to the preparation and presentation of financial statements, including related business processes and information exchange;

(d) Control activities;

(e) Monitoring controls.

This division does not necessarily reflect how the entity designs, implements, and maintains internal controls or how those components are classified. Auditors may use different terms or provisions to represent the different components of internal control and their impact on the audit, provided that all components described in this Standard are addressed.

A52. Paragraphs A69–A104 of this Standard provide guidance on the application of five components of internal control related to the audit of financial statements. Appendix 01 of this Standard provides additional components of internal control.

The characteristics of manual and automated elements in internal control affect the auditor's risk assessment.

A53. The entity's internal control system comprises both manual and automated elements. The characteristics of the manual and automated elements are relevant to the auditor's risk assessment and the subsequent audit procedures based on that assessment.

A54. The use of manual or automated elements in internal control also affects how transactions are created, recorded, processed, and reported:

(1) Manual controls may include approval procedures, review of transactions, reconciliation and tracking of such reconciliations. In addition, the unit may use automated controls to create, record, process and report transactions electronically to replace paper documents.

(2) Controls in information technology systems are a combination of both automatic controls (e.g., controls designed in computer programs) and manual controls. In addition, manual controls may be independent of information technology, may use data from the information technology system, or may be limited to monitoring the effectiveness of information technology, the effectiveness of automatic controls, and to addressing exceptional circumstances. When using information technology to create, record, process, and report transactions or other financial data for inclusion in financial reporting, the systems and software programs may include controls relating to the corresponding underlying data for material accounts, or controls that are decisive for the effectiveness of manual controls that are dependent on information technology.

The combination of manual and automated elements in an organization's internal control depends on the characteristics and complexity of the information technology system in use.

A55. In general, information technology offers many benefits to internal control. Information technology enables the organization to:

(1) Consistently apply established operating rules, perform complex calculations when handling large volumes of transactions and data;

(2) Improve the timeliness, availability and accuracy of information;

(3) Facilitate information analysis;

(4) Improve the ability to monitor the unit's operations, as well as monitor the unit's policies and procedures;

(5) Reduce the risk of controls being disabled;

(6) Improve the ability to achieve efficiency in task allocation by applying security controls in application programs, databases and operating systems.

A56. Information technology can also pose specific risks to the internal controls of an organization, for example:

(1) Trusting a system or program while the system or program incorrectly processes data or uses incorrect data for processing, or both situations;

(2) Unauthorized access to data can result in data deletion or alteration, including unauthorized accounting of transactions, accounting of fictitious transactions, or accounting of inaccurate transactions. These risks increase when multiple users access a shared database;

(3) The possibility of IT system personnel having more privileged access than necessary for their assigned duties, thus breaking the division of responsibilities;

(4) Unauthorized changes to original data;

(5) Unauthorized changes to the system or program;

(6) Failure to make the necessary changes to the system or program;

(7) Inaccurate manual intervention;

(8) The possibility of data loss or inability to access data when requested.

A57. Manual elements in internal control may be more appropriate for situations requiring judgment and prudence, for example:

(1) Large, unusual or non-recurring transactions;

(2) Situations where errors are difficult to identify and difficult to predict;

(3) Frequently changing situations require additional controls beyond the scope of existing automatic controls;

(4) Monitoring the effectiveness of automatic control.

A58. Manual controls in internal control are generally less reliable than automated controls because manual controls can be easily overlooked, manipulated, and prone to simple errors. Manual controls may also not guarantee consistency. Manual controls are generally unsuitable in the following situations:

(1) Large and frequently recurring transaction volumes, or predictable error situations, can be prevented, detected and corrected by automated controls;

(2) Control activities whose implementation methods can be designed and automated appropriately.

A59. The scope and characteristics of risks to internal control often vary depending on the nature and characteristics of the entity's information system. The entity addresses risks arising from the use of information technology or manual elements in internal control by designing effective controls based on the characteristics of its information system.

Controls related to the audit

A60. The entity's objectives are directly related to the controls implemented to provide reasonable assurance that those objectives will be achieved. However, not all of the entity's objectives and controls relating to financial reporting, operations, and compliance are relevant to the auditor's risk assessment.

A61. When auditors judge whether a single control or a combination of controls is relevant to the audit, factors to consider include:

(1) Importance;

(2) The severity of the associated risks;

(3) Size of the unit;

(4) Characteristics of the unit's business operations, including characteristics of the unit and its owner;

(5) Diversity and complexity in the unit's operations;

(6) Current legal regulations;

(7) The situations and components of internal control application;

(8) Characteristics and complexity of the internal control systems of the unit, including the use of service providers;

(9) The existence and manner in which a particular control, individually or in combination with other controls, can prevent, detect and correct material misstatements.

A62. Controls over the completeness and accuracy of information provided by the entity may be relevant to the audit if the auditor intends to use that information to design and perform subsequent audit procedures. Controls relating to operational objectives and compliance may also be relevant to the audit if those controls relate to data that the auditor evaluates or uses when performing audit procedures.

A63. Internal controls for safeguarding assets to prevent unauthorized acquisition, use, and disposal may include controls relating concurrently to the preparation and presentation of financial statements and the entity’s operational objectives. The auditor’s assessment of these controls is typically limited to procedures relating to the reliability of the financial statements.

A64. An entity often has controls over certain objectives that are irrelevant to the audit, and therefore the auditor does not need to consider these controls. For example, the entity may rely on complex automated control systems to ensure operational efficiency and performance (e.g., an airline's automated control system ensures on-schedule flight operations), however, these controls may be irrelevant to the audit. Furthermore, although internal controls may apply throughout the entire entity, or within any given business unit or business cycle, knowledge of the internal controls relevant to that business unit or business cycle may be irrelevant to the audit.

Notes on auditing public sector entities

A65. When auditing entities in the public sector, auditors often have more responsibilities regarding the review of internal controls. For example, auditors must report on the entity's compliance with regulations on administrative spending. Auditors also have additional responsibilities for reporting on compliance with laws and regulations. Therefore, the review of internal controls can be broader and more detailed.

Content and level of understanding of relevant controls (Guidance in paragraph 13 of this Standard)

A66. When evaluating the design of a control, the auditor should consider whether that control, individually or in combination with other controls, is capable of effectively preventing, detecting, and correcting material misstatements. A control being implemented means that it exists and is being used by the entity. If a control is ineffective, evaluating its implementation is not very meaningful; therefore, the design of the control should be considered first. An inappropriately designed control can be a material defect in the entity's internal control.

A67. Risk assessment procedures to obtain audit evidence regarding the design and implementation of related controls may include:

(1) Interview the unit's personnel;

(2) Observe the application of specific controls;

(3) Review reports and documents;

(4) Check transactions on the information system related to financial reporting.

To achieve the objective of gathering audit evidence, if the auditor uses interview procedures, they must use them in combination with other procedures.

A68. An auditor's knowledge of the entity's controls alone is insufficient to assess their effectiveness unless the entity has automated measures in place to ensure consistent control performance. For example, audit evidence showing that a manual control was performed at one point in time cannot demonstrate its effectiveness at other points in the audit period. However, due to the inherent consistency of information technology processes (see paragraph A55 of this Standard), depending on the auditor's assessment, audit procedures aimed at determining whether an automated control was performed may also be used to assess its effectiveness. Vietnamese Auditing Standard 330 provides guidance on assessing the effectiveness of controls.

Components of internal control – Control environment (Guidance in paragraph 14 of this Standard)

A69. The control environment includes the governance and management functions, the views, perceptions, and actions of the Board of Directors and the Management Board regarding internal control and the importance of internal control to the entity's operations. The control environment shapes the overall characteristics of an entity and directly impacts the awareness of each member of the entity regarding control work.

A70. To understand the entity's control environment, the auditor may need to consider the following elements of the control environment:

(a) Communicating information and requirements for the enforcement of integrity and ethical values.These are key factors that influence the effectiveness of designing, operating, and monitoring controls;

(b) Commitment to competence: The Board of Directors' consideration of the levels of competence required for each specific task, and the corresponding necessary skills and knowledge;

(c) Board of Directors' involvement:

(1) Independent of the unit's Board of Directors;

(2) Having experience and position;

(3) The level of participation of the Board of Directors, the information received by the Board of Directors and the careful consideration of activities;

(4) The reasonableness of the actions of the Board of Directors, including the complexity of the questions asked and followed up by the Board of Directors, and the way the Board of Directors works with internal and independent auditors.

(d) The philosophy and management style of the Board of Directors:

(1) Approaches to managing and accepting business risks;

(2) Views and actions regarding the preparation and presentation of financial statements;

(3) Views on information processing, accounting and human resources.

(e) Organizational structureThe framework within which the unit's activities are planned, implemented, controlled, and reviewed in order to achieve its objectives;

(f) Assignment of authority and responsibility: The method of assigning authority and responsibility for activities; the method of establishing reporting procedures and the division of authority and responsibility among different levels;

(g) Human resources policies and practices: Policies and practices relating to recruitment, orientation, training, evaluation, guidance, promotion, compensation, bonuses, and corrective actions.

Audit evidence regarding elements of the control environment

A71. Appropriate audit evidence regarding elements of the control environment can be obtained by combining interview procedures and other risk assessment procedures, such as verifying interview results through observation or document examination. For example, by interviewing management and employees, the auditor learns how management communicates its views to employees on business practices and ethical conduct. The auditor will then determine whether the corresponding controls have been implemented by considering factors such as whether management has a written code of ethics and whether they act in accordance with that code.

The influence of the control environment on the assessment of material misstatement risk.

A72. Several elements of the entity's control environment significantly influence the assessment of material misstatement risk. For example, the entity's Board of Directors will significantly influence the entity's perception of control, as one of its responsibilities is to balance the pressures placed on the Board of Management regarding the preparation and presentation of financial statements, which may arise from market demands and payroll planning. The effectiveness of designing a control environment involving the participation of the Board of Directors is influenced by issues such as:

(1) The independence of the Board of Directors from the Board of Management and the ability to evaluate the performance of the Board of Management;

(2) The Board of Directors' understanding of the unit's business operations;

(3) The extent to which the Board of Directors assesses the conformity of the financial statements with the applicable financial reporting framework.

A73. Among the elements of the control environment, an independent and active Board of Directors can influence the philosophy and work style of its members. However, some other elements of the control environment may have only limited effectiveness. For example, human resource policies and practices aimed at recruiting competent finance, accounting, and information technology personnel may reduce the risk of errors in the processing of financial information but cannot eliminate the tendency for the Board of Directors to report higher profits than they actually are.

A74. When auditors assess the risk of material misstatement, the existence of an adequate control environment can be a positive factor for the entity. However, an adequate control environment can help reduce the risk of fraud but cannot prevent fraud entirely. Conversely, deficiencies in the control environment can reduce the effectiveness of controls, especially against fraud. For example, the failure of management to allocate sufficient resources to address information technology security risks can adversely affect internal controls by allowing inappropriate changes to computer programs, data alterations, or unauthorized transaction processing. As guided in paragraphs A2–A3 of Vietnamese Auditing Standard 330, the control environment also influences the content, timing, and scope of subsequent audit procedures.

A75. The control environment itself cannot prevent or detect and correct a material misstatement. However, the control environment can influence the auditor's assessment of the effectiveness of other controls (e.g., the monitoring of controls and the operation of specific control activities) and, therefore, influence the auditor's assessment of the risk of material misstatement.

Notes on auditing small entities

A76. The control environment in a small entity often differs from that in a large entity. For example, the board of directors in a small entity may not have independent or external members, and governance may be undertaken by the owner who is also the director of the entity, as there are no other owners. The characteristics of the control environment can influence the importance of other controls, or influence the absence of other controls. For example, an active owner-director may reduce the risk of a lack of separation of responsibilities in a small entity; however, this may increase other risks such as the risk of controls being compromised.

A77. In addition, audit evidence regarding factors in the control environment in small entities may not be documented, such as communication between management and staff that may be informal but effective. For example, a small entity may not have a written code of business ethics but instead builds a corporate culture that emphasizes the importance of integrity and ethical conduct through the words and example of management.

A78. Therefore, when examining the control environment of a small entity, auditors should pay particular attention to the views, perceptions, and actions of the Board of Directors or the owner who is also the Director of the entity.

Components of internal control – The entity's risk assessment process (Guidance in paragraph 15 of this Standard)

A79. An entity's risk assessment process forms the basis for management to identify risks that need to be managed. A risk assessment process appropriate to the entity's circumstances, nature, size, and complexity can help auditors identify risks of material misstatement. Auditors must use professional judgment to determine whether the entity's risk assessment process is appropriate.

Considerations when auditing small entities (guidance in paragraph 17 of this Standard)

A80. Small entities often lack formally established risk assessment processes. In this case, management typically identifies risks through direct involvement in the business. Nevertheless, auditors should still interview management about the identified risks and how they address them.

Components of internal control – Information systems related to the preparation and presentation of financial reports, including related business processes, and information exchange.

Information systems related to the preparation and presentation of financial statements, including related business processes (guidance in paragraph 18 of this Standard).

A81. Information systems relating to the purpose of preparing and presenting financial statements, including accounting systems, comprising procedures and documents designed and constructed to:

(1) To create, record, process and report the entity's transactions (as well as events and conditions) and maintain related liability for assets, liabilities and equity;

(2) Resolving misprocessed transactions, for example, tracking and settling pending items in a timely manner;

(3) Handling and explaining ways in which controls may be controlled or bypassed;

(4) Transfer data from the transaction processing system to the General Ledger;

(5) Gather information related to financial reporting on events and conditions other than transactions occurring, such as asset depreciation and changes in the collectibility of receivables;

(6) Ensure that the information required to be disclosed in accordance with the applicable financial reporting framework has been collected, recorded, processed, summarized and presented appropriately in the financial statements.

Journal entries

A82. An entity's information system typically includes common journal entries used repeatedly to record transactions. For example, journal entries to record in the General Ledger transactions related to revenue, purchases, payments, or periodically recording management's accounting estimates such as changes in estimates of the collectibility of accounts receivable.

A83. In the process of preparing and presenting financial statements, the entity also uses atypical journal entries to record infrequent transactions, unusual transactions, or adjustments. Examples of atypical journal entries include: adjusting entries when preparing consolidated financial statements, entries when consolidating or liquidating business operations, or estimates of asset impairment. In a manual accounting system, auditors can identify atypical journal entries by examining detailed ledgers, journal entries, and related documents. When using an automated accounting system, such entries may only exist in electronic data form; therefore, auditors can more easily identify them using computer-assisted auditing techniques.

Relevant business processes

A84. The business processes of an entity are activities designed to:

(1) Developing, purchasing, producing, selling and distributing the unit's products and services;

(2) Ensuring compliance with laws and regulations;

(3) Record information, including accounting information and financial reporting information.

An entity's business processes generate transactions that are recorded, processed, and reported by its information systems. Understanding these business processes, including how transactions occur, helps auditors understand the entity's information systems in relation to the preparation and presentation of financial statements in a manner appropriate to the entity's circumstances.

Notes on auditing small entities

A85. In smaller entities, the information systems and business processes related to the preparation and presentation of financial statements are often less complex but no less important than in larger entities. Smaller entities with active management may not require overly detailed accounting instructions, complex accounting systems, or written policies. Therefore, when auditing a small entity, auditors can more easily learn about the systems and processes and may rely more on interview procedures than on document review. However, understanding the systems and processes remains crucial even for audits of small entities.

Information exchange (guidance in paragraph 19 of this Standard)

A86. The unit's communication regarding roles, responsibilities, and significant issues related to financial reporting should also provide insights into the roles and responsibilities of individuals involved in internal control over financial reporting. This communication should include aspects such as an individual's understanding of the relationship between their work within the financial reporting information system and the work of others, and how to report exceptional circumstances to appropriate management levels within the unit. This communication may take the form of policy guidance documents and financial reporting guidance documents. Open communication channels help ensure that exceptional circumstances are reported and addressed.

Notes on auditing small entities

A87. Information exchange in smaller units may be less complex and easier than in larger units due to fewer management levels and easier access to the Board of Directors.

Components of internal control – Control activities (Guidance in paragraph 20 of this Standard)

A88. Control activities are policies and procedures designed to ensure that the directives of the Board of Directors are implemented. Whether in information technology or manual systems, control activities have diverse objectives and are applied at different organizational and functional levels of the unit. Examples of specific control activities include those related to:

(1) Approval;

(2) Performance evaluation;

(3) Information processing;

(4) Physical controls (safety locks, safes, cameras, etc.);

(5) Task division.

A89. The control activities related to the audit are:

(1) Control activities that involve significant risks and control activities that involve risks for which substantive testing alone would not provide sufficient appropriate audit evidence, as provided for in paragraphs 29 and 30 of this Standard; or

(2) Control activities are determined to be relevant in the auditor's judgment.

A90. The auditor's judgment as to whether a control is relevant to the audit is influenced by the risks the auditor has identified as potentially giving rise to material misstatement, and whether the auditor believes that testing the effectiveness of that control is necessary to determine the scope of substantive testing.

A91. Auditors may focus on identifying and understanding control activities in areas perceived to have a higher risk of material misstatement. When multiple control activities are directed toward a single objective, the auditor does not need to understand each control activity related to that objective.

A92. From understanding the other components of internal control, the auditor will know what controls the entity has or does not have in place, thereby helping the auditor determine whether further investigation into those controls is necessary.

Notes on auditing small entities

A93. The principles of control in small entities are generally similar to those in large entities; however, the methods of operation may differ. Additionally, in small entities, some control activities may be inappropriate because management already exercises control. For example, having only management authority to grant credit to customers and approve large purchases may allow for tight control over significant accounts and transactions, reducing or eliminating the need for other detailed control activities.

A94. Control activities related to audits of small entities are typically found within key business cycles such as revenue, procurement, and employee expenses.

Risks arising from information technology (guidance in paragraph 21 of this Standard)

A95. The use of information technology affects how control activities are performed. From the auditor's perspective, controls over information technology systems (including general information technology controls and application program controls) are considered effective when they maintain the integrity of information and the security of data processed by the information system.

A96. General IT controls are policies and procedures relating to a wide range of application programs and supporting the effective operation of application program controls. General controls apply to large-scale, small-scale, and end-user environments. General IT controls maintain information integrity and data security and typically include controls over:

(1) Data center and network connectivity activities;

(2) Purchasing, changing and maintaining software systems;

(3) Change the program;

(4) Secure access;

(5) Procurement, development and maintenance of application systems.

These controls are typically implemented to address the risks outlined in paragraph A56 of this Standard.

A97. Application program controls are manual or automated procedures, typically operating at the business cycle level and applied to the transaction processing of individual application programs. Application program controls can be preventative or detectative and are designed to ensure the integrity of accounting data. Therefore, application program controls relate to procedures used to create, record, process, and report transactions or other financial data. These controls aim to ensure that transactions are fully and accurately approved, recorded, and processed. Examples include automated input data validation, sequential numbering combined with manual tracking of exceptional or corrected aggregate reports at the time of data entry.

Components of internal control – Monitoring controls (Guidance in paragraph 22 of this Standard)

A98. Monitoring controls is the process of evaluating the effectiveness of internal controls at each stage. This process includes assessing the effectiveness of controls in a timely manner and taking necessary corrective measures. Management monitors controls through ongoing activities, separate assessments, or a combination of both. Ongoing monitoring activities are typically associated with the repetitive activities of an entity and include routine management and oversight activities.

A99. The Board of Directors' oversight activities also utilize externally gathered information such as customer complaints and regulatory comments that may identify problems or areas for improvement.

Notes on auditing small entities

A100. The management's oversight of controls is typically demonstrated by the close involvement of the management or owner-cum-director in the entity's operations. This helps the management detect significant discrepancies between reality and expectations and uncover inaccurate financial data, thereby enabling appropriate corrective action for those controls.

Internal audit (guidance in paragraph 23 of this Standard)

A101. The internal audit of the audited entity may be relevant to the audit if the responsibilities and activities of this entity are related to the preparation and presentation of the entity's financial statements and the auditor intends to use the work of the internal auditor to change the substance, timing, or scope of the audit procedures to be performed. If the auditor determines that the work of the internal auditor is relevant to the audit, the auditor should apply the provisions and guidance of Vietnamese Auditing Standard No. 610.

A102. The objectives, responsibilities, and role of internal audit within an entity may vary depending on the entity's size, organizational structure, and the requirements of the Board of Directors and Management. Internal audit responsibilities may include monitoring internal controls, risk management, and assessing compliance with laws and regulations. Alternatively, internal audit responsibilities may be limited to evaluating the economy, efficiency, and performance of operations, and therefore may not involve the preparation of the entity's financial statements.

A103. If the internal audit's responsibilities relate to the preparation of the entity's financial statements, the independent auditor should consider the activities that the internal audit has performed or will perform, which may include reviewing the internal audit's plan for the period, if any, and discussing that plan with the internal auditor.

Sources of information (guidance in paragraph 24 of this Standard)

A104. Much of the information used in monitoring activities may be provided by the entity's information systems. If management assumes that the data used for monitoring is accurate without a basis for that assumption, the information may be flawed, leading management to draw erroneous conclusions from monitoring activities. Therefore, auditors must understand the entity's monitoring activities as a component of internal control, including:

(1) Information sources related to the unit's monitoring activities;

(2) The basis for the Board of Directors to believe that the information is reliable for monitoring purposes.

Identify and assess the risk of material misstatement.

Assessing the risk of material misstatement at the financial reporting level. (Guidance in paragraph 25(a) of this Standard)

A105. Risks of material misstatement at the financial statement level are risks that have a pervasive impact on multiple items in the financial statements and potentially affect multiple assertions. These risks may not be detectable with respect to specific assertions at the transaction group, account balance, or disclosures. These risks represent situations that could increase the risk of material misstatement at the assertion level, for example, management controlling internal controls. Risks at the financial statement level may relate to the auditor's consideration of the risk of material misstatement due to fraud.

A106. Risks at the financial reporting level may arise from deficiencies in the control environment (although these risks may also be related to other factors, such as a deteriorating economic situation). For example, the incompetence of the Board of Directors can seriously affect the financial reporting; therefore, the auditor needs to take comprehensive measures to address this risk.

A107. An auditor's understanding of internal controls may lead to doubts about the entity's ability to perform an audit of its financial statements. For example:

(1) Serious concerns about the integrity of the entity's management led the auditor to conclude that the risk of misrepresentation of information by the management in the financial statements was so great that the audit could not be performed;

(2) Concerns about the condition and reliability of the entity's records and documents lead the auditor to conclude that it is unlikely that sufficient appropriate audit evidence can be obtained to issue a fully unqualified audit opinion on the financial statements.

A108. Vietnamese Auditing Standard No. 705 provides guidance for auditors to determine whether it is necessary to issue a qualified or disclaimed audit opinion, or, in certain circumstances, withdraw from the audit if permitted by law and regulations.

Assess the risk of material misstatement at the assertion level. (Guidance in paragraph 25(b) of this Standard)

A109. Auditors should consider the risk of material misstatement at the assertion level for groups of transactions, account balances, and disclosures, as this will directly support the determination of the substance, timing, and scope of subsequent assertion-level audit procedures necessary to obtain sufficient appropriate audit evidence. When identifying and assessing the risk of material misstatement at the assertion level, auditors may conclude that the identified risk has a more widespread impact on the overall financial statements and a potential impact on multiple assertions.

Using databases

A110. To affirm that the financial statements comply with the applicable financial reporting framework, management should formally or implicitly affirm the underlying basis for the recognition, measurement, presentation, and disclosure of the components of the financial statements and related disclosures.

A111. The evidence used by auditors to consider potential misstatements is divided into three categories and may take the following forms:

(a) The underlying data for the groups of transactions and events during the audited period:

(i) Existence: the recorded transactions and events have occurred and relate to the entity;

(ii) Completeness: all transactions and events that need to be recorded have been recorded;

(iii) Accuracy: The figures and data relating to recorded transactions and events are reflected appropriately;

(iv) Timely: transactions and events are recorded in the correct accounting period;

(v) Classification: transactions and events are recorded in the correct accounts.

(b) The basis for the account balances at the end of the period:

(i) Existence: assets, liabilities, and equity actually exist;

(ii) Rights and obligations: the entity holds rights relating to assets owned by the entity and has obligations relating to liabilities;

(iii) Completeness: all assets, liabilities, and equity that need to be recognized have been fully recognized;

(iv) Valuation and allocation: Assets, liabilities, and equity are presented in the financial statements at appropriate values, and any adjustments relating to valuation or allocation are appropriately recognized.

(c) The supporting sources for the presentations and explanations:

(i) Existence, rights and obligations: events, transactions and other matters disclosed actually occurred and are relevant to the entity;

(ii) Completeness: all disclosures required to be presented in the financial statements have been presented;

(iii) Classification and comprehensibility: financial information is presented, interpreted, and explained logically, clearly, and comprehensibly;

(iv) Accuracy and value: financial and other information is presented fairly and at its appropriate value.

A112. The auditor may use the assertions described above or may express them differently provided that all of the above is addressed. For example, the auditor may combine assertions relating to transactions and events with assertions relating to account balances.

Notes on auditing public sector entities

A113. When explaining the basis for the financial statements of public sector entities, in addition to the basis listed in paragraph A111 of this Standard, management shall generally assert that the transactions and events were conducted in compliance with law and regulations. Such basis may also fall within the scope of the financial statement audit.

The process for identifying risks of material misstatement. (Guidance in paragraph 26(a) of this Standard)

A114. Information gathered from performing risk assessment procedures, including audit evidence obtained from evaluating the design of controls and determining whether those controls are implemented, is used as audit evidence to support the risk assessment. The risk assessment will determine the nature, timing, and scope of subsequent audit procedures to be performed.

A115. Appendix 02 This Standard provides examples of situations and events that may indicate the existence of a risk of material misstatement.

Connect the controls with the data sources. (Guidance in paragraph 26(c) of this Standard)

A116. During the risk assessment process, auditors need to identify controls that can prevent or detect and correct material misstatements for each specific assertion. Generally, auditors need to understand the controls and relate them to the assertions within the cycles and systems in which those controls are located, as individual controls alone are usually insufficient to address the risk. Typically, only the combination of multiple controls with other components of internal control is sufficient to address the risk.

A117. Conversely, some control activities may have a specific impact on individual assertions within a particular group of transactions or account balances. For example, control activities designed by the entity to ensure that its employees accurately count and record inventory during annual inventory counts will directly relate to the assertion of the existence and completeness of inventory balances.

A118. Controls may be directly or indirectly related to an assertion. The less a control is related to an assertion, the less effective it is in preventing, detecting, and correcting errors in that assertion. For example, a sales manager's review procedure of sales activities at specific stores by region is only indirectly related to the assertion of the completeness of sales revenue. Therefore, this control may be less effective in mitigating the risk to the assertion of “completeness” than other directly related controls, such as the procedure for reconciling shipping documents with sales invoices.

Significant risk

Identify significant risks (guidance in paragraph 28 of this Standard)

A119. Significant risk is often associated with unusual transactions or matters requiring judgment. Unusual transactions are those with unusual values ​​or characteristics, and therefore occur infrequently. Matters requiring judgment may include accounting estimates whose valuation contains significant uncertainty. Frequent, simple transactions handled systematically usually carry less significant risk.

A120. For unusual transactions, the risk of material misstatement is often higher and arises from issues such as:

(1) Greater intervention by the Board of Directors in accounting;

(2) More manual intervention in the data collection and processing process;

(3) Complex accounting calculations or principles;

(4) The infrequent nature of the transactions makes it difficult for the entity to effectively exercise controls over those risks.

A121. For matters requiring significant judgment relating to accounting estimates, the risk of material misstatement is often greater and arises from issues such as:

(1) Accounting principles for accounting estimates or revenue recognition may be interpreted differently;

(2) The necessary judgments may be subjective or complex or require assumptions about the impact of future events, such as judgments about fair value.

A122. Paragraphs 15–21 of Vietnamese Auditing Standard 330 stipulate that the impact of identifying a risk is significant on subsequent audit procedures.

Significant risks are associated with the risk of material misstatement due to fraud.

A123. Paragraphs 25–27 of Vietnamese Auditing Standard 240 provide more detailed provisions on identifying and assessing the risk of material misstatement due to fraud.

Identify the controls related to significant risks (guidance in paragraph 29 of this Standard).

A124. Although risks associated with unusual or judgmental matters are generally outside the scope of ordinary controls, management may have other measures in place to address such risks. Therefore, the auditor should investigate whether the entity has designed and implemented controls for significant risks arising from unusual or judgmental matters, whether management has measures in place to address such risks, and what those measures are. These measures may include:

(1) Control activities such as reviewing assumptions made by management or experts;

(2) Record the estimation process;

(3) Approval of the Board of Directors.

A125. For example, for one-time events such as receiving notification of a significant lawsuit, the auditor needs to consider the entity's handling of the matter, including issues such as: whether the case was assigned to appropriate experts (such as legal counsel within or outside the entity), whether the entity conducted an assessment of the potential impacts, and how the entity intends to disclose the matter in its financial statements.

A126. In some cases, the controls applied by management to risks of material misstatement may still fail to address these risks. This is an indication of a serious deficiency in the entity's internal controls (see guidance in paragraph A7 of Vietnamese Auditing Standard 265).

These are risks that, if only basic testing were performed, would not provide sufficient appropriate audit evidence. (Guidance in paragraph 30 of this Standard)

A127. Risks of material misstatement may be directly related to the recording of frequently occurring groups of transactions or account balances and the reliable preparation of financial statements. Such risks may include risks of incorrect or incomplete processing of significant and frequently occurring groups of transactions such as revenue, purchases, and cash receipts and disbursements.

A128. When such routine business transactions are handled with a high degree of automation, with little or no manual intervention, auditors cannot apply substantive testing alone to these risks. This is the case, for example, when a large amount of the entity's information is created, recorded, processed, or reported solely in electronic form, such as within an integrated system. In such situations:

(1) Audit evidence can only be in electronic form and the adequacy and appropriateness of audit evidence often depend on the effectiveness of controls over the accuracy and completeness of information;

(2) The likelihood of information being created or altered inappropriately and going undetected may be greater if appropriate controls are not effectively implemented.

A129. Paragraph 08 of Vietnamese Auditing Standard No. 330 specifies the subsequent audit procedures when the aforementioned risks are identified.

Review the risk assessment. (Guidance in paragraph 31 of this Standard)

A130. During an audit, the auditor may find information that differs significantly from the information used to assess risk. For example, the risk assessment may be based on the auditor's expectation of the effectiveness of certain controls. When testing these controls, the auditor may obtain audit evidence showing that those controls were not effective at some point during the audit. Similarly, when performing substantive tests, the auditor may discover numerical errors or errors that occur more frequently than the auditor expected when assessing risk. In such situations, the risk assessment may not adequately reflect the entity's actual situation, and the subsequent audit procedures that have been planned may not be effective in detecting material misstatements (see further provisions and guidance in Vietnamese Auditing Standard No. 330).

Audit documents and records (Guidance in paragraph 32 of this Standard)

A131. Auditors must use professional judgment to determine how to maintain audit documentation as required in paragraph 32 of this Standard. For example, when auditing small entities, this documentation may be incorporated into the overall audit strategy and audit plan documentation (see paragraphs 07–09 of Vietnamese Auditing Standard 300). Similarly, the results of a risk assessment may be documented separately, or recorded as part of the audit documentation on subsequent audit procedures (see paragraph 28 of Vietnamese Auditing Standard 330). The form and level of detail of the documentation are influenced by the nature, size and complexity of the entity and its internal controls, the availability of information from the entity, and the audit methodology and techniques applied during the audit.

A132. For entities with business lines and processes related to the preparation and presentation of financial statements that are not complex, the audit file may be simple in form and concise in content. The audit file does not need to reflect the auditor's entire understanding of the entity and related issues, but only needs to record the key understanding, including the information the auditor used to assess the risk of material misstatement.

A133. The level of documentation can also reflect the experience and capabilities of the audit team members. Provided compliance with the provisions and guidance of Vietnamese Auditing Standard No. 230, compared to an audit performed by a highly experienced audit team, an audit team comprising less experienced members may require more detailed audit documentation to help them gain appropriate insights into the audited entity.

A134. For routine audits, certain documents may be brought in and updated, if necessary, to reflect changes in the entity's operations or processes.

Appendix 01

(Guidance in paragraph 04(c), 14–24, A69–A104 of this Standard)

COMPONENTS OF INTERNAL CONTROL

This Appendix provides more detail on the components of internal control as referred to in paragraphs 04(c), 14–24 and A69–A104 of this Standard, which are relevant to the audit of financial statements.

A. Controlled environment

The control environment includes the following elements:

(1). Communicating information and requirements for the enforcement of integrity and ethical values: The effectiveness of controls cannot be greater than the ethical values ​​and integrity of those who create, manage, and supervise those controls. Integrity and ethical conduct are products of the organization's ethical and behavioral standards, as well as their communication and enforcement in practice. The enforcement of integrity and ethical values ​​includes measures by management to eliminate or minimize incentives for employees to engage in dishonest, illegal, or unethical actions. Communicating the organization's policies on integrity and ethical values ​​may include communicating behavioral standards to employees through organization policies, codes of ethics, and exemplary conduct.

(2). Commitment to competence: Competence refers to the knowledge and skills necessary to complete tasks within an individual's job scope.

(3). Participation of the Board of Directors: The board of directors has a significant influence on the entity's perception of control. The board has important responsibilities, which are addressed in professional standards, laws and other regulations, or in guidance issued by the board. In addition, the board is responsible for overseeing the design and effectiveness of procedures for reporting misconduct and procedures for reviewing the effectiveness of the entity's internal controls.

(4). Philosophy and management style of the Board of Directors: The management philosophy and style of the Board of Directors are characterized by many factors, such as their views, attitudes, and actions regarding the preparation and presentation of financial statements, which may be reflected in their cautious or less cautious selection of accounting principles when there are many different choices of accounting principles, or the discretion and prudence in constructing accounting estimates.

(5). Organizational structure: Establishing an appropriate organizational structure involves considering key issues regarding authority, responsibility, and suitable reporting channels. The suitability of the organizational structure depends in part on the size and operational characteristics of the unit.

(6). Assignment of powers and responsibilities: Delegating authority and responsibility may include policies relating to common practices, the understanding and experience of key personnel, and the resources provided to perform the task. Additionally, delegation may include policies and communication to ensure that all employees understand the unit's objectives, how each individual's actions relate to and contribute to those objectives, and are aware of each individual's responsibilities and accountability.

(7). Human resources policies and practices: Human resource policies and practices often reveal important issues related to the organization's perception of control. For example, standards for hiring the most qualified candidates (emphasizing educational background, prior work experience, past achievements, and evidence of integrity and ethical conduct) demonstrate the organization's commitment to competent and trustworthy individuals. Training policies that communicate future roles and responsibilities, including activities such as training schools and workshops, reflect expected job performance and behavior. Promotions based on periodic performance reviews demonstrate the organization's commitment to appointing capable personnel to higher responsibilities.

B. The unit's risk assessment process

(1). For the purpose of preparing and presenting financial statements, the entity's risk assessment process includes how management identifies business risks related to the preparation and presentation of financial statements within the framework of financial reporting, estimates the level of risk, assesses the likelihood of risk occurrence, and decides on actions to address, manage risk, and the resulting outcomes. For example, the entity's risk assessment process might include assessing how the entity considers the possibility of under-recording transactions, or how it identifies and analyzes significant estimates recognized in the financial statements.

(2). Risks related to the reliability of financial statements include events inside or outside the entity, transactions or circumstances that may arise and adversely affect the ability to create, record, process and report financial data in accordance with the Management’s assertions in the financial statements. Management may develop programs, plans or actions to address specific risks or decide to accept risks due to economic efficiency or other considerations. Risks may arise or change in circumstances such as:

– Changes in the operating environment: Changes in the legal or operating environment can lead to significant changes in competitive pressures and various other risks;

– New staffNew personnel may have different understandings and priorities regarding internal control;

– New or modified information systemsSignificant and rapid changes in information systems can alter the risks associated with internal controls;

– Rapid growthSignificant and rapid expansion of operations can put pressure on controls and increase the risk of control failure;

– New technologyThe application of new technologies to production processes or information systems can alter the risks in internal controls;

– New activities, products, and business modelsEngaging in business areas or transactions in which the entity has little experience may lead to new risks related to internal controls;

– Unit restructuringRestructuring may lead to staff reductions, management changes, or changes in the division of responsibilities, altering the risks associated with internal controls;

– Expanding operations overseas: Expanding or acquiring overseas operations introduces new and unusual risks that may affect internal controls, for example, increased or altered risks from foreign exchange transactions;

– Implement new accounting regulations: The adoption of new accounting principles or changes to existing accounting principles can affect the risks involved in the preparation and presentation of financial statements.

C. Information systems related to the preparation and presentation of financial reports, including related business processes and information exchange.

(1). An information system includes machinery and equipment (hardware), software, personnel, procedures, and data. Many information systems make extensive use of information technology (IT).

(2). Information systems related to the purpose of preparing and presenting financial statements, including financial reporting systems, which include methods and records for:

– Identify and record all valid transactions;

– Describe transactions in a timely and detailed manner to allow for appropriate classification of transactions for the preparation and presentation of financial statements;

– Measure the value of transactions to ensure that the transaction value is fairly reflected in financial statements;

– Determine the period in which the transaction takes place in order to record the transaction in the correct accounting period;

– Appropriately present transactions and related disclosures in the financial statements.

(3). The quality of information generated from the system will affect the ability of the Board of Directors to make appropriate decisions in managing and controlling the unit's operations and to prepare financial reports reliably.

(4). The exchange of information, relating to providing insights into the roles and responsibilities of individuals associated with internal control over the preparation and presentation of financial statements, may take the form of policy guidance documents, accounting and financial reporting guidelines. The exchange of information may also take the form of electronic, verbal and through actions of the Board of Directors.

D. Control activities

In general, the control activities associated with an audit can be categorized into policies and procedures related to:

(1) Assessing the operational situation: These control activities include evaluating and analyzing actual performance against plans, forecasts, or previous performance; assessing and analyzing the relationships between different relevant data, such as operational and financial data, and identifying and correcting errors; comparing internal figures with external sources of information and evaluating the performance of functions or activities.

(2) Information processingTwo common types of information system control are application program control and general IT control. Application program control is applied to the processing of individual applications, for example, checking the arithmetic accuracy of recorded data, maintaining and reviewing account balances and trial balances, automated controls such as input data entry checks, and sequential numbering checks, combined with manual monitoring of exceptional summary reports. General IT control consists of policies and procedures related to multiple applications and supports the effective operation of application program controls by helping to ensure the normal functioning of the information system. Examples of general IT control include: controlling program changes, controlling access to systems or data, controlling the application of new software, controlling software to restrict access or monitoring the use of system features that could alter financial data or change records without leaving a trace.

(3) Physical controlThese controls include:

– Ensuring the physical security of assets, including hiring security personnel and using means to ensure safe access to assets and documents;

– Authority to access computer programs and data files;

– Periodically count and compare actual figures with figures recorded in the books (for example, compare the results of physical cash, securities, and inventory counts with the accounting records).

The extent to which physical controls aimed at preventing theft of assets are related to the reliability of financial reporting, and therefore to the quality of the audit, depends on how vulnerable the assets are to theft.

(4) Assignment of duties: Assigning different individuals the responsibilities for approving transactions, recording transactions, and overseeing and safeguarding assets. This division of responsibilities aims to reduce the opportunity for any single individual to both violate and conceal wrongdoing or fraud in the course of their normal duties.

Certain control activities may depend on the existence of appropriate policies at a higher level established by the Board of Directors or the Management Board. For example, authority controls may be delegated according to established guidelines, such as investment criteria set by the Management Board; or infrequent transactions such as large acquisitions or liquidations may require higher-level approval, in some situations possibly the approval of the general meeting of shareholders.

E. Monitoring controls

(1). A key responsibility of the Board of Directors is to establish and maintain internal controls on a regular basis. The Board's oversight of controls includes reviewing whether these controls are functioning as intended and whether they are being modified appropriately in response to changes in the entity. Oversight of controls may include activities such as: the Board reviewing whether bank reconciliation statements have been prepared in a timely manner, internal auditors assessing the compliance of sales department staff with the entity's regulations on sales contracts, the legal department monitoring compliance with the entity's ethical standards and operating policies, etc. Oversight is also to ensure that controls continue to function effectively over time. For example, without oversight of bank reconciliation statements, the personnel responsible may not prepare them.

(2). Internal auditors or personnel performing similar functions may participate in monitoring the entity's controls through separate assessments. Typically, these individuals provide regular information on the operation of internal controls, and focus attention on evaluating the effectiveness of internal controls, and exchange information on strengths and weaknesses as well as make recommendations for improving internal controls.

(3). Monitoring activities may include using information obtained through exchanges with external parties that may reveal problems or areas for improvement. Customers often verify information in invoices through bill payments or claims for amounts due. In addition, regulatory bodies may also inform the entity about issues that may affect the operation of internal controls, for example, information related to an inspection by a banking regulator. At the same time, when conducting monitoring activities, the Board of Directors may also review information exchanges from independent auditors related to internal controls.

Appendix 02

(Guidance on paragraphs A33 and A115 of this Standard)

SITUATIONS AND EVENTS THAT MAY SHOW THE RISK OF MATERIAL ERRORS

Below are examples of situations and events that may indicate the existence of a risk of material misstatement. The examples include a wide variety of situations and events; however, not all of these situations and events are relevant to every audit, and the examples below may not be exhaustive.

(1) Activities in economically unstable areas, for example, in countries where the currency is severely depreciated, or where the economy is experiencing high inflation;

(2) Activities affected by market changes, e.g., futures trading;

(3) Activities related to legal regulations are highly complex;

(4) Going concern or liquidity issues, including loss of key customers;

(5) Limitations on capital and credit;

(6) Changes in the industry in which the unit is operating;

(7) Changes in the supply chain;

(8) Developing or introducing new products and services, or using new production lines;

(9) Expanding the scope of operations to many new areas;

(10) Changes within the unit such as major procurement activities, restructuring or other unusual events;

(11) Expected sale of business unit or segment;

(12) There are many complex joint venture and partnership relationships;

(13) Using off-balance sheet financing, special purpose entities or complex financial arrangements;

(14) There were notable transactions with related parties;

(15) Shortage of personnel with suitable qualifications in accounting and financial reporting;

(16) Changes in key personnel, including the resignation of key executives;

(17) Deficiencies in internal control, especially those not addressed by the Board of Directors;

(18) Conflict between the unit's information technology strategy and business strategy;

(19) Changes in the information technology environment;

(20) Install new, important information technology systems related to financial reporting;

(21) Investigation by State management agencies into the unit's financial activities or results;

(22) Past errors or mistakes or significant adjustments at the end of the year;

(23) Extraordinary transactions of significant value, including intercompany transactions and large year-end revenue transactions;

(24) Transactions recognized for the purposes of the Board of Directors, for example, refinancing of debt, assets being prepared for sale or the classification of securities that are tradable on the market;

(25) Applying new accounting regulations;

(26) Accounting measurements involve complex procedures;

(27) Events or transactions involving measurements of substantial uncertainty, including accounting estimates;

(28) Unresolved litigation and contingent liabilities, for example, sales warranties, financial guarantees and environmental compensation./.

*****

Zalo